Garmin Fenix 8 vs Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm

*As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Garmin Fenix 8 wins

Garmin Fenix 8 vs Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm: video reviews

Reviews worth watching before you buy. A video loads only when you press play.

Garmin Fenix 88

Garmin Fenix 8 is the best Garmin watch; the base model is excellent and unlikely to disappoint, though the Pro is overkill.

  • Accurate GPS and heart rate close to Apple Watch Ultra 2
  • Dynamic routing quickly recovers after going off route
  • Auto-generated maps in Garmin Connect caused awkward routes

Garmin Fenix 8 is a top-tier watch that performs very well overall, but it is too expensive at full price, so wait for sales.

  • Strong performance and battery life
  • Comfortable to wear and good build quality
  • Very high price, hard to justify at full retail

Garmin Fenix 8 is comfortable, stylish and durable, and the best Garmin right now, despite weak battery life.

  • Excellent screen-to-body ratio for a small wrist
  • GPS accuracy clearly improved in dense forest running
  • Battery life is weak with the always-on display

Garmin Fenix 8 is a worthy upgrade from older Garmin watches, with excellent battery life, but not needed for Fenix 7 owners.

  • Battery life of about two weeks between charges
  • Nicer display than older Garmin models
  • Always-on display missing at first, requiring settings changes

Garmin Fenix 8 is a favourite watch for training and endurance, though Apple remains stronger for smart features and notifications.

  • Training metrics and recovery insight
  • Golf course maps and automatic shot tracking with club sensors
  • Weaker texting, notifications and app ecosystem than Apple

Garmin Fenix 8 is still a favourite after a year and worth the price, though the jet lag advisor and some features could improve.

  • Altitude acclimation readings are useful at high altitude
  • Sunrise, sunset, moon and dawn information helps plan runs
  • Jet lag advisor is hard to follow and cannot be planned in advance

Garmin Fenix 8 is the most versatile Garmin for everyday use and multisport, durable and very useful despite its high price.

  • Versatile for everyday wear and many sports
  • Morning report with training readiness and sleep score
  • Heavier than an Apple Watch and uncomfortable on bony wrists after hours

Garmin Fenix 8 is a premium, accurate sports watch and an excellent choice for new buyers, though upgrading from recent models isn't worth it.

  • Robust, high-quality premium build
  • Vibrant AMOLED display
  • Price is hefty
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm8

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is better than expected overall, with an improved battery, but scratch-prone glass and a disliked strap hold it back.

  • Slim, light design that stays comfortable on a small wrist
  • Smooth performance and quick charging
  • Glass scratches easily; no sapphire crystal

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm, the larger model, is the more attractive choice with a convincing overall package.

  • Familiar premium design that sits well on mid-size wrists
  • Large battery margin in the creator's demanding test
  • Some new health features still need time to prove their value

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is a well-built watch that is good enough for marathon training and running in big cities.

  • Accurate GPS routes on streets lined with tall buildings
  • Well-built watch
  • Route jumped into the road after leaving the underground section

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is very strong for sports and fitness, with accurate GPS and heart rate, though treadmill distance was off.

  • Heart rate accuracy comparable to Apple Watch
  • GPS tracks are clear and accurate on outdoor runs
  • Treadmill distance undercounted by about a mile on a five-mile run

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is a strong watch with good gestures, but software gaps make the cheaper Pixel Watch 4 worth considering.

  • Gestures for reading texts and navigating feel well integrated
  • A wrist shake reliably takes you back one menu level
  • Gestures cannot be customised per app

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is a great Android smartwatch, but the battery and small upgrade over Pixel Watch 4 give little urgency to buy.

  • Fast charging and a docking system that doubles as a clock
  • Smooth performance and an easy-to-use interface
  • Battery lasts about a day and a half, so it needs charging daily

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is easy to recommend overall, but some of its best features still feel unfinished.

  • Attractive dome display with a premium design
  • Battery lasts around 50 hours in the creator's test
  • Not the battery champion next to some rival watches

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is a great smartwatch, but only a small upgrade, so Pixel Watch 4 owners should not bother upgrading.

  • Premium, comfortable design with easy strap swaps
  • Smooth performance and a clear user interface
  • Small upgrade over the Pixel Watch 4, not a revolution

Garmin Fenix 8 vs Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm: written reviews

Tests of each product by expert websites, with what they liked and missed.

Garmin Fenix 86
  • 43% battery left after an 8-hour backcountry hike with maps on
  • Buzzes when you stray 25 to 45 feet off route and offers a way back; ClimbPro shows upcoming gradients and time to the summit
  • Multi-band GPS mode can't last a 30-hour ultra race; Full charge takes 90 to 120 minutes
  • Solar 47mm model rated for 21 days in smartwatch mode, longer with solar charging
  • Built-in microphone and speaker for calls and voice commands
  • Can't upload your own trail maps
runmorph.comin Spanish8.5 / 10
  • SatIQ switches to dual-band GPS in forest or city canyons
  • TopoActive offline color maps with contour lines
  • 43-hour GPS battery is short for ultras lasting 48 hours or more
  • Over a week of battery life with daily use on the 47mm
  • Speaker and mic for calls from the wrist when paired with a phone
  • Headline battery figures mostly apply to the 51mm model
hrdlpn.nlin Dutch
  • Voice notes for recording ideas on the wrist; Speaker and microphone for voice commands
  • Bright AMOLED screen that stays readable in sunlight
  • Voice notes are hard to export to Google or your calendar
wielrenner.euin Dutch
  • Up to 84 hours of GPS use, good for long outdoor trips
  • Room for 2,000 songs, played through Bluetooth earbuds or a speaker
  • Looks much like the previous generation
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm2
  • Battery lasts about 2.5 to 3 days per charge, up from about two
  • Charging from 20% to 100% takes around 40 minutes
  • Health Guardian feature not yet available, due in October
  • GPS matched the Apple Watch Ultra 3 and Garmin Fenix 8 Pro in a marathon
  • Heart rate readings close to a Polar H10 chest strap
  • Battery lasts only 1.5 to 2 days with the always-on display on

Garmin Fenix 8 vs Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm: direct comparison

The radar shows each spec group. Next to it: only the specs that differ, the better value ticked. Open a row for the explanation.

246810HealthFitnessBatterySmart featuresConnectivityDisplay & DesignHardware
Garmin Fenix 8Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Display & Design: Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm wins 5 of 9 · 8.9 vs 7.9
9 differences✓ = better value
Display brightness1,000 nits3,000 nits▶
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a brighter screen than Garmin Fenix 8 (3,000 nits vs 1,000 nits). The average smartwatch peaks at 750 nits.What it is: The peak brightness of the screen, measured in nits, which determines how easily it can be read in direct sunlight.When it matters: When you run or cycle outdoors on sunny days and need the screen readable without shading it with your hand.
Waterproof depth rating100 m50 m▶
The Garmin Fenix 8 has 100 m, the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm 50 m. That's thicker than 92% of smartwatches.What it is: The maximum depth in metres the watch is rated to be submerged in still water without leaking.When it matters: When you swim in a pool or open water, or dive or snorkel with the watch on your wrist.
Screen size1.3 inch1.4 inch▶
The Garmin Fenix 8 has 1.3 inch, the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm 1.4 inch. That's smaller than 67% of smartwatches.What it is: The diagonal size of the display in inches, measured across the active screen area.When it matters: Matters if you read long messages, follow maps or check detailed workout graphs often, though bigger screens add bulk on small wrists.
Weight59 g36.7 g▶
The Garmin Fenix 8 has 59 g, the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm 36.7 g. That's heavier than 75% of smartwatches.What it is: The mass of the complete watch including case, strap and battery, measured in grams.When it matters: When you wear it to bed for sleep tracking or all day, since extra grams add up on a smaller wrist.
Release date20242026▶
The Garmin Fenix 8 has 2024, the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm 2026. That's higher than 83% of smartwatches.What it is: The year the watch model was first released, which hints at how modern its chipset, sensors and operating system are.When it matters: Matters most when buying a discounted or second-hand model, since older releases tend to lose software and app updates sooner.
Thickness13.8 mm12.3 mm▶
The Garmin Fenix 8 has 13.8 mm, the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm 12.3 mm. That's thicker than 87% of smartwatches.What it is: The depth of the case from the back to the top of the glass, which determines how much it protrudes from the wrist.When it matters: When you wear it under a shirt cuff or a jacket sleeve, where a thick case snags and sits awkwardly.
Resolution454x 454448x 448▶
Garmin Fenix 8 has a display resolution of 454x 454 which is higher than that of 76.5% of smartwatches and equal to that of 7% of smartwatches. Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a display resolution of 448x 448 which is higher than that of 75.4% of smartwatches.What it is: The total number of pixels available on the watch display.When it matters: When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Height43 mm45 mm▶
The Garmin Fenix 8 has 43 mm, the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm 45 mm. That's smaller than 67% of smartwatches.What it is: The vertical size of the case from top to bottom, which sets how much of the wrist the watch covers.When it matters: When you have a narrow wrist or wear the watch under a sleeve, where a tall case can feel bulky.
4wins for Garmin Fenix 8
5wins for Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm

Garmin Fenix 8 vs Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm in best-of listsA best-of list is an article such as “Best smartwatches” by a test site, a magazine or a YouTube reviewer. We count every list that includes the product and the rank it got there. “#1 or award” means it is ranked first or named the best in a category. Best-of lists make up 30% of the overall score.

Ranks in independent best-of lists from test sites, magazines and YouTube. Click a list to open it.

Garmin Fenix 8

Garmin Fenix 8

On more lists27listsThe number of best-of lists from test sites, magazines and YouTube reviewers that include the Garmin Fenix 8.
3#1 or award in 3 of 27 listsLists that rank the Garmin Fenix 8 first, or name it the best in a category (for example best value or best overall).
4top 3 in 4 of 27Lists that rank the Garmin Fenix 8 first, second or third, plus the awards.
Named best forTriathlon watch overallAll-purpose smartwatchOverallPremium GarminRuggedLifestyle and health smartwatches
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm

20listsThe number of best-of lists from test sites, magazines and YouTube reviewers that include the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm.
–#1 or awardLists that rank the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm first, or name it the best in a category (for example best value or best overall).
1top 3 in 1 of 20Lists that rank the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm first, second or third, plus the awards.
Named best forSmartwatch for Android usersAndroid smartwatchAndroid smartwatch for most peopleMost android usersAndroid usersAndroid

What reviewers say about the Garmin Fenix 8 and Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm

Topics that expert and video reviewers praise or criticise. Open a topic to read what they wrote.

Garmin Fenix 8
Garmin Fenix 8 · 18 reviews

Reviewers praise the long battery life, tough premium build and voice features, but many feel it's overpriced and cellular support disappoints.

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm · 13 reviews

Battery life, accurate GPS and smooth software impress, but most say it barely improves on its predecessor and feels overpriced.

14 praise · 7 criticise
Battery lifereviewers
6 praise · 3 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
43% battery left after an 8-hour backcountry hike with maps onmountaineerjourney.com
Solar 47mm model rated for 21 days in smartwatch mode, longer with solar chargingbusinessinsider.com
Over a week of battery life with daily use on the 47mmreviewgadget.nl
Up to 84 hours of GPS use, good for long outdoor tripswielrenner.eu
Long battery life during trainingMission Triathlon (video)
Battery lasts about a week with regular workouts; Fast charging, around one hourAndrea T-Prod (video)
Long battery life, from about five days with GPS to 20 dayseSavants (video)
GPS-mode battery lasts 28 to 30 hoursMatt LeGrand (video)
Battery life is outstandingSport Technik (video)
Long battery life in GPS-only modeBlog Montre cardio GPS (video)
Seven-day battery life with always-on displayAlessandro Morolla (video)
Long battery lifeeSavants (video)
Longer battery life than beforeChase the Summit (video)
Battery lasts over a week with light trainingRafael Zeier (video)
Multi-band GPS mode can't last a 30-hour ultra race; Full charge takes 90 to 120 minutesmountaineerjourney.com
43-hour GPS battery is short for ultras lasting 48 hours or morerunmorph.com
Headline battery figures mostly apply to the 51mm modelreviewgadget.nl
Battery drops to about five days with constant GPS useeSavants (video)
Music playback cuts battery life to about 10 hoursMatt LeGrand (video)
Charging is slow, cable only, with no wireless optioneSavants (video)
Proprietary charging cable that is easy to loseRafael Zeier (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Battery lasts about 2.5 to 3 days per charge, up from about twoandroidheadlines.com
Battery improved, lasting around 48 hours with mixed useTech Spurt (video)
Battery life is good for its sizeTechnikfaultier (video)
Battery lasts two to three days with heavy useSmartWorld (video)
Battery life of around two days, more on the 45mmADSLZone (video)
Battery lasts around two daysBautsch Sportstec (video)
Battery lasts only 1.5 to 2 days with the always-on display onglobal.techradar.com
Battery still not outstanding for a smartwatchTech Spurt (video)
Battery life still around 40 hours, no real gainEveryday Legends (video)
5 praise · 5 criticise
Software and appreviewers
5 praise · 1 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
No technical problems during testingDC Rainmaker (video)
Software problems largely fixed over three monthsMission Triathlon (video)
Data screens stay on the chosen page during runningBeyond Running (video)
Reworked user interface and navigationChase the Summit (video)
Frequent software updates keep improving featuresRafael Zeier (video)
Steep learning curve for new usersmountaineerjourney.com
Garmin Connect app feels dated and cumbersome to navigate; Physical buttons and new layout take time to get used to; Initial setup takes timeAndrea T-Prod (video)
Launched with many software problems, needing more than seven updateseSavants (video)
Early software problems, reportedly fixed by updateseSavants (video)
Unclear whether new software reaches older watchesChase the Summit (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Smooth performance and quick chargingTech Spurt (video)
Software stands out from other smartwatches; Notifications and camera images can be viewed right on the wristFunThomas (video)
Smooth performance and a clear user interfaceChase the Summit (video)
Polished Wear OS software and Android integrationSmartWorld (video)
Fast, smooth interface and quick app launchesEveryday Legends (video)
Only the processor is slightly betterBautsch Sportstec (video)
1 praise · 7 criticise
Pricereviewers
7 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Many more features and newer software than the older modelBeyond Running (video)
Looks much like the previous generationwielrenner.eu
Price increase is hard to justifyDC Rainmaker (video)
Many premium features may not be needed; Cheaper Garmin models offer strong alternativesMatt LeGrand (video)
Upgrading from Fenix 7 or 7 Pro is hardly worth it; Most changes are minor software updates; Price is high even for the premium segmentSport Technik (video)
Few sports changes compared with the previous generation; Limited gains for Fenix 7 owners; High price, though promotions are expected later; Cheaper Fenix E lacks microphone, speaker and new heart sensorBlog Montre cardio GPS (video)
Premium price not needed by every athleteAlessandro Morolla (video)
Price is very high for the top modelsChase the Summit (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Price has not come down at launchTechnikfaultier (video)
Price is too high for the changes madeBNR Tech (video)
Price is hard to justifyFunThomas (video)
Health Coach and full sleep monitoring need a monthly subscriptionTuttoTech (video)
High prices, especially for the LTE variant; Cheaper smartwatches offer many of the same core featuresSmartWorld (video)
High price for what it offersADSLZone (video)
Higher price than the previous modelEveryday Legends (video)
5 praise
GPS accuracyreviewers
5 praise · 1 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
SatIQ switches to dual-band GPS in forest or city canyonsrunmorph.com
Accurate GPS and heart rate trackingDC Rainmaker (video)
Multi-band GPS stays accurate in city canyons; SatIQ switches GPS modes to save batteryMatt LeGrand (video)
Accurate GPS and heart rate during running and cyclingSport Technik (video)
Reliable GPS for navigating new routesAlessandro Morolla (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
GPS matched the Apple Watch Ultra 3 and Garmin Fenix 8 Pro in a marathonglobal.techradar.com
GPS tracks are clear and accurate on outdoor runsDesFit (video)
Very accurate heart rate and GPS dataTuttoTech (video)
Improved GPS accuracy, with results after post-processingChase the Summit (video)
Better GPS accuracy in citiesEveryday Legends (video)
Improved GPS only works after the run, not liveChase the Summit (video)
7 praise · 3 criticise
Audio and voicereviewers
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Built-in microphone and speaker for calls and voice commandsbusinessinsider.com
Voice notes for recording ideas on the wrist; Speaker and microphone for voice commandshrdlpn.nl
Speaker and mic for calls from the wrist when paired with a phonereviewgadget.nl
Room for 2,000 songs, played through Bluetooth earbuds or a speakerwielrenner.eu
Flashlight, payments and voice assistant now built inAndrea T-Prod (video)
Built-in microphone and speaker for calls and musicBlog Montre cardio GPS (video)
Voice control added to the watchRafael Zeier (video)
Voice notes are hard to export to Google or your calendarhrdlpn.nl
Speaker and microphone rarely usefulDC Rainmaker (video)
Call volume is somewhat low; Offline voice commands see little real useAlessandro Morolla (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
5 praise · 4 criticise
Maps and navigationreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Buzzes when you stray 25 to 45 feet off route and offers a way back; ClimbPro shows upcoming gradients and time to the summitmountaineerjourney.com
Full-color topographic maps with turn-by-turn directions; ClimbPro shows gradient, distance and elevation for upcoming climbsbusinessinsider.com
TopoActive offline color maps with contour linesrunmorph.com
Round-trip routing builds a loop to a set distance and rerouteswielrenner.eu
Route recalculation that cheaper watches lackeSavants (video)
Can't upload your own trail mapsbusinessinsider.com
Map zooming can take seconds, slower than rivalsreviewgadget.nl
No turn alerts in navigationMission Triathlon (video)
Maps are clunky to explore, and picking destinations is hardeSavants (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
not mentioned
Change from previous modelreviewers
1 praise · 8 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8Not mentioned by reviewers.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Slightly brighter display and a slightly faster chipBNR Tech (video)
Almost no visual difference from the previous modelBNR Tech (video)
Looks almost identical to Watch 4 apart from the softwareFunThomas (video)
Little change from the previous year's modelTuttoTech (video)
Small upgrade over the Pixel Watch 4, not a revolutionChase the Summit (video)
Little change compared with the previous generationSmartWorld (video)
Little change from the previous generationADSLZone (video)
Little difference in use compared with the Watch 4Everyday Legends (video)
Hardware almost unchanged from the Pixel Watch 4Bautsch Sportstec (video)
6 praise · 2 criticise
Displayreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Bright AMOLED screen that stays readable in sunlighthrdlpn.nl
Bright AMOLED screen with deeper colors and sharper mapsreviewgadget.nl
Customisable colours and screen settingsBeyond Running (video)
Colourful, bright AMOLED displaySport Technik (video)
Larger display with slimmer bezelBlog Montre cardio GPS (video)
Better solar and AMOLED displaysChase the Summit (video)
Display sometimes needs a wrist turn to show dataMission Triathlon (video)
Solar display looks a bit dull and slightly less clearBeyond Running (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
not mentioned
Health featuresreviewers
3 praise · 5 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8Not mentioned by reviewers.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Sleep tracking catches the exact moment you wake up; Breathing Emergency Detection calls emergency services if you don't respondglobal.techradar.com
Health features such as blood pressure and sleep breathing tracking; Smart wake feature that feels slightly more refreshingBNR Tech (video)
Strong health and fitness tracking tied to Google's appADSLZone (video)
Health Guardian feature not yet available, due in Octoberandroidheadlines.com
Health features are not fully accurate and do not replace a doctorBNR Tech (video)
Blood pressure and other new health features not usable yetFunThomas (video)
Some readiness and cardio load values seem oddTuttoTech (video)
Blood pressure trend feature not yet FDA-approvedEveryday Legends (video)
7 praise
Build and designreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Premium titanium and sapphire buildeSavants (video)
Titanium case and sapphire glass feel durableBeyond Running (video)
Robust, high-quality buildSport Technik (video)
Sapphire glass option resists scratchesBlog Montre cardio GPS (video)
Physical buttons usable while wearing glovesAlessandro Morolla (video)
Improved build and buttonsChase the Summit (video)
Improved design and OLED displayRafael Zeier (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
6 praise · 1 criticise
Sports and trainingreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Solid performance in diving and trainingDC Rainmaker (video)
Reliable across all sportsMission Triathlon (video)
Among the best sports tracking and data ecosystems availableAndrea T-Prod (video)
Deep tracking for dozens of sports, plus training featureseSavants (video)
Morning report helps plan the dayAlessandro Morolla (video)
Strong performance across many sportseSavants (video)
Not the best fit for gym-focused trainingAndrea T-Prod (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
not mentioned
Chargingreviewers
5 praise · 2 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8Not mentioned by reviewers.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Charging from 20% to 100% takes around 40 minutesandroidheadlines.com
Charging much faster than the previous Samsung watchTechnikfaultier (video)
Fast charging with the included chargerSmartWorld (video)
Fast charging is a standout strengthEveryday Legends (video)
Charges quicklyBautsch Sportstec (video)
Wireless charging is awkward on the curved strapChase the Summit (video)
Charger that many people dislikeADSLZone (video)
3 praise · 3 criticise
Divingreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Rated for diving to 40 m, with a depth gaugerunmorph.com
Dive computer rated to 40 m, with leak-free induction buttonsreviewgadget.nl
Useful diving and surf featureseSavants (video)
Diving and wrist calls matter to few buyershrdlpn.nl
Diving and wrist calls matter to few buyersreviewgadget.nl
Dive mode has to be started by handeSavants (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
not mentioned
Design and comfortreviewers
4 praise · 1 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8Not mentioned by reviewers.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Slim, light design that stays comfortable on a small wristTech Spurt (video)
Comfortable to wear day and night, including sleep; Pleasant design with a round, classic lookTechnikfaultier (video)
Comfortable, premium design that still appealsTuttoTech (video)
Premium, comfortable design with easy strap swapsChase the Summit (video)
Side button sits too flush and is hard to pressChase the Summit (video)
not mentioned
AI featuresreviewers
1 praise · 4 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8Not mentioned by reviewers.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Gemini works offline for simple tasks like timers and alarmsandroidheadlines.com
Gemini sometimes sends you back to your phone to confirm a route; Gemini briefly stopped working entirely during testingglobal.techradar.com
AI features feel unnecessary for everyday useTechnikfaultier (video)
Feels like a gimmick at timesBNR Tech (video)
AI coach sometimes gives no feedback during the dayDesFit (video)
4 criticise
Cellular connectivityreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Lacks LTE and inReach, which only the Fenix 8 Pro offersrunmorph.com
No cellular, so your phone must be with you to call or messagehrdlpn.nl
No calls or messages without a phone nearbywielrenner.eu
No cellular connectivityDC Rainmaker (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
not mentioned
Heart rate accuracyreviewers
3 praise · 1 criticise
▶
Garmin Fenix 8Not mentioned by reviewers.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Heart rate readings close to a Polar H10 chest strapglobal.techradar.com
Heart rate accuracy comparable to Apple WatchDesFit (video)
Heart rate readings are very accurate during strength trainingBautsch Sportstec (video)
Heart rate spikes are occasionally missed in a single workoutBautsch Sportstec (video)
3 criticise
Size and weightreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Big case that feels bulky on the wrist; Solar charging, LTE and satellite only on larger sizes, a letdown for smaller wristsbusinessinsider.com
Weighs 72 g with the silicone strap, which you notice over long distancesrunmorph.com
Large case, so less comfortable to wear at nightBeyond Running (video)
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by reviewers.

Green = reviewers praise it, red = they criticise it. Counts are reviews that mention the topic.

What owners say about the Garmin Fenix 8 and Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm

From owners' comments under review videos. Open a topic to read what owners report.

57%positive

Garmin Fenix 8

219 owners57% positive9% mixed34% negative

Owners praise battery life and vivid displays, while software bugs and slow maps dampen an otherwise strong watch.

72%positive

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm

83 owners72% positive6% mixed22% negative

Owners praise quick charging, long battery life and smooth design, while workout tracking gaps and battery limits frustrate some.

28 like it · 11 dislike it
Batteryowners mention
32 like it · 4 dislike it
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Long battery life between chargesThe AMOLED 51mm lasts about 13 days with AOD on, and close to the stated 29 days without AOD or activities. Solar MIP versions can run for weeks.28 owners
Battery life falls short in useBattery falls short with AMOLED, with AOD on, frequent GPS use or LTE. Owners report about 6 to 13 days instead of the stated 29.11 owners
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Quick charging makes daily top ups easyFast charging in the shower or while getting ready fully tops up the watch, so owners rarely worry about charge level.19 owners
Battery often lasts two days or longerOwners report two to three days or about 40 to 68 hours per charge, shorter with always-on display turned on.13 owners
Battery life still needs improvementSome owners say battery life falls short of two days, especially with always-on display turned on.4 owners
31 like it · 5 dislike it
Screenowners mention
3 like it
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Clear, easy-to-read screenThe MIP screen stays clear and easy to read outdoors, in bright sun and at side glances, without needing a wrist gesture.21 owners
Always-on MIP stays readable outdoorsThe always-on MIP screen shows the time and data at all times without a gesture. It stays readable outdoors and in bright sun, where owners find AMOLED hard to see.10 owners
AMOLED is hard to read outdoorsThe AMOLED screen is hard to read in bright sun, while riding, running or on glaciers. Owners say the MIP version is far easier to see outdoors.5 owners
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Improved display with responsive touchOwners say the round display responds to touch well and has improved screen quality over previous Pixel Watch models.3 owners
5 like it · 25 dislike it
GPS, maps and altitudeowners mention
8 like it
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Helpful maps and outdoor toolsBuilt-in preloaded topo maps and offline navigation help owners on hikes and trips. Owners say the maps help keep them on route.5 owners
Slow interface and map loadingMaps are slow to load and redraw when panned, and route calculation takes minutes. The interface and voice assistant also feel laggy.15 owners
Navigation lacks basic map and route toolsOwners cannot enter an address on the watch, and the apnea maps have no zoom. Some trails are missing from the topo maps.10 owners
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Smooth, responsive everyday performanceOwners find navigation and apps respond quickly and run smoothly, a clear step up from the Pixel Watch 1 and 3 and rival smartwatches.8 owners
16 like it · 7 dislike it
Comfort and sizeowners mention
4 like it · 3 dislike it
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Handy built-in flashlightThe built-in flashlight is bright and owners use it often. Some say it is brighter than the Fenix 7.9 owners
Comfortable fit across wrist sizesOwners with smaller wrists find the 47mm comfortable and not bulky. The 51mm is described as bulky for some.7 owners
Large case feels bulky or heavyOwners find the 51mm case bulky and heavy on the wrist, and say the display is small for the case size.7 owners
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Slim shape and comfortable strapsOwners find the watch slim, not bulky, and it does not catch on sleeves; the straps are comfortable and some use their own bands.4 owners
Gestures misfire or feel confusingSome owners say gesture controls work only occasionally; setting the correct wrist in the orientation setting improves detection.3 owners
6 like it · 21 dislike it
Messages, apps and phoneowners mention
3 like it
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Voice controls make quick tasks easierVoice commands let owners set timers, alarms and start activities hands-free. The speaker and mic let them use a phone assistant from the wrist.6 owners
LTE and satellite connections are unreliableSatellite messaging and LTE calls are hit or miss, with messages failing in the same spot on the way back. Some owners in Australia and Europe report no satellite service.9 owners
Limited apps and messaging features6 owners
Weak speaker and microphone soundOwners find the speaker volume weak, almost unusable, and the microphone quality poor. Phone calls have a long delay.6 owners
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Pairs well with Pixel phones and budsOwners say the watch works well with Pixel phones and pairs easily with Pixel Buds.3 owners
15 like it
Build and designowners mention
7 like it · 3 dislike it
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Durable, solid-feeling constructionOwners say the case and sapphire glass hold up to hard knocks and daily work. One dropped his onto tile with no damage.8 owners
Sleek look and premium feelOwners find the design sleek and premium, with a black DLC or titanium finish that pairs well with many bands.7 owners
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Attractive design earns regular complimentsOwners say the slim, sleek round design looks good and draws compliments, and a metal case band makes it look more premium.7 owners
Scratches easily without sapphire glassOwners say the watch scratches easily because it has no sapphire glass, and small scratches appear from everyday use.3 owners
23 dislike it
Sleep trackingowners mention
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Frequent software bugs and crashesOwners report frequent bugs, including random reboots during activities, crashes when swiping the widgets, sleep data replaced by nap data, and lost workouts.23 owners
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by owners.
13 like it
Heart rate and healthowners mention
5 like it · 3 dislike it
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
Useful health and sports tracking featuresThe watch tracks many sports, plus ECG, SpO2, recovery and training readiness. Owners use it for golf, swimming, cycling, hiking and freediving, and one used its CGM link underwater.13 owners
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Helpful health coaching and activity trackingOwners find the activity and sleep tracking more accurate than before, and the coaching prompts and health features useful.5 owners
Some features are missing or delayedSome owners say health features such as ECG and fall detection are unavailable in their country or not yet released.3 owners
12 dislike it
Price and valueowners mention
not mentioned
▶
Garmin Fenix 8
High price for the performanceOwners say the price is high for the performance, given the software bugs and slow processing.12 owners
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmNot mentioned by owners.
not mentioned
Sports and fitnessowners mention
4 dislike it
▶
Garmin Fenix 8Not mentioned by owners.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm
Limited gym and activity trackingOwners say the exercise app lacks gym workouts, custom workouts and exercises like bicep curls, so strength training is generic.4 owners

All specs: Garmin Fenix 8 vs Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm

Winner

Garmin Fenix 8Garmin Fenix 8

Google Pixel Watch 5 45mmGoogle Pixel Watch 5 45mm

Price

Overall score
9.1
8.8
Technical score
9.1
Garmin Fenix 8 has the highest technical score.
8.6
Popularity
8.8
Garmin Fenix 8 has the highest popularity.
6.9
Reviews score
8.2
8.3
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm: Reviews score
Value for money
9.3
Garmin Fenix 8 has the highest value-for-money score.
9.2
Running
10
9.2
Swimming
9.9
9.2
Health monitoring
9.2
9.6
Sleep tracking
10
8.2
Hiking
10
9.6
Seniors
8.3
7.0
Health
9.3
9.1
Heart rate monitor
yes
What it is
A built-in sensor that measures your pulse directly from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a heart rate monitor. 9.5% of smartwatches include a heart rate monitor.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
A built-in sensor that measures your pulse directly from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a heart rate monitor. 9.5% of smartwatches include a heart rate monitor.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Blood oxygen monitoring
yes
What it is
A wrist-based feature that estimates blood oxygen saturation over time.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports blood oxygen monitoring. 30.4% of smartwatches support blood oxygen monitoring.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
A wrist-based feature that estimates blood oxygen saturation over time.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports blood oxygen monitoring. 30.4% of smartwatches support blood oxygen monitoring.
Priority:
MEDIUM
ECG
yes
What it is
The ability to record a single-lead electrocardiogram from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports ECG. 82% of smartwatches support ECG.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
The ability to record a single-lead electrocardiogram from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports ECG. 82% of smartwatches support ECG.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Irregular heart rate warnings
?
yes
What it is
Notifications that flag heart-rate patterns which appear unusually irregular.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports irregular heart rate warnings. 49.5% of smartwatches support irregular heart rate warnings.
Priority:
LOW
HRV tracking
yes
What it is
Measurement of heart-rate variability, the change in timing between heartbeats.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports HRV tracking. 54.9% of smartwatches support HRV tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
Measurement of heart-rate variability, the change in timing between heartbeats.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports HRV tracking. 54.9% of smartwatches support HRV tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Blood pressure monitoring
?
?
Temperature sensor
yes
What it is
A sensor that records skin or wrist temperature changes and longer-term trends.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a temperature sensor. 68.2% of smartwatches include a temperature sensor.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
A sensor that records skin or wrist temperature changes and longer-term trends.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a temperature sensor. 68.2% of smartwatches include a temperature sensor.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Fingertip sensor
no
What it is
Whether the smartwatch includes a dedicated fingertip-contact health sensor.
When it matters
When you want faster spot checks or more precise fingertip-based health measurements on the watch itself.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not include a fingertip sensor. 0.8% of smartwatches include a fingertip sensor.
Good value:
🎯 yes
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
Whether the smartwatch includes a dedicated fingertip-contact health sensor.
When it matters
When you want faster spot checks or more precise fingertip-based health measurements on the watch itself.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not include a fingertip sensor. 0.8% of smartwatches include a fingertip sensor.
Good value:
🎯 yes
Priority:
LOW
Stress monitoring
yes
What it is
Stress estimates derived from heart rate, HRV, or similar body signals.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports stress monitoring. 31.3% of smartwatches support stress monitoring.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Stress estimates derived from heart rate, HRV, or similar body signals.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports stress monitoring. 31.3% of smartwatches support stress monitoring.
Priority:
LOW
Sleep tracking
yes
What it is
Automatic recording of sleep duration, stages, or sleep quality from overnight wear.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports sleep tracking. 6.2% of smartwatches support sleep tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
Automatic recording of sleep duration, stages, or sleep quality from overnight wear.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports sleep tracking. 6.2% of smartwatches support sleep tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Perspiration monitoring
yes
What it is
Support for sweat-related sensing or estimates tied to perspiration during wear or training.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 tracks perspiration. 85% of smartwatches track perspiration.
Priority:
LOW
?
Calorie intake tracking
?
?
VO2 max measurement
yes
What it is
Estimated VO2 max, a fitness metric linked to aerobic capacity and endurance.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 measures VO2 max. 48.8% of smartwatches measure VO2 max.
Priority:
MEDIUM
?
Readiness score
yes
What it is
A recovery-style score that combines recent activity, sleep, and body data into one summary.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports readiness scores. 80.3% of smartwatches support readiness scores.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A recovery-style score that combines recent activity, sleep, and body data into one summary.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports readiness scores. 80.3% of smartwatches support readiness scores.
Priority:
LOW
Weight tracking
yes
What it is
Logging or syncing of body-weight records over time.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports weight tracking. 58.1% of smartwatches support weight tracking.
Priority:
LOW
?
Water intake tracking
yes
What it is
Logging tools for recording daily water consumption.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Fenix 8 tracks water intake. 55.9% of smartwatches track water intake.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Fenix 8 tracks water intake.
no
What it is
Logging tools for recording daily water consumption.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not track water intake. 44.2% of smartwatches track water intake.
Priority:
LOW
Menstrual cycle tracking
?
?
Inactivity alerts
yes
What it is
Reminders that prompt you to move after long periods of inactivity.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports inactivity alerts. 7.4% of smartwatches support inactivity alerts.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Reminders that prompt you to move after long periods of inactivity.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports inactivity alerts. 7.4% of smartwatches support inactivity alerts.
Priority:
LOW
Smart scale compatibility
yes
What it is
Compatibility with smart scales for syncing weight and body-composition data.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports smart scale compatibility. 43% of smartwatches support smart scale compatibility.
Priority:
LOW
?
Release date
2024
What it is
The year the watch model was first released, which hints at how modern its chipset, sensors and operating system are.
When it matters
Matters most when buying a discounted or second-hand model, since older releases tend to lose software and app updates sooner.
Garmin Fenix 8 was released in 2024, which is more recent than 83.3% of Smartwatches and the same as 7.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 2023 or newer
Priority:
LOW
2026
What it is
The year the watch model was first released, which hints at how modern its chipset, sensors and operating system are.
When it matters
Matters most when buying a discounted or second-hand model, since older releases tend to lose software and app updates sooner.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm was released in 2026, which is more recent than 97.1% of Smartwatches and the same as 2.9% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 2023 or newer
Priority:
LOW
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is the most recently released model.
Brand name
Garmin
Google
Fitness
9.9
9.1
Accelerometer
yes
What it is
A motion sensor that measures acceleration, steps, gestures, and general movement.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes an accelerometer. 0.5% of smartwatches include an accelerometer.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A motion sensor that measures acceleration, steps, gestures, and general movement.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes an accelerometer. 0.5% of smartwatches include an accelerometer.
Priority:
LOW
Barometer
yes
What it is
A pressure sensor used for altitude changes, elevation estimates, and weather-related context.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a barometer. 46.5% of smartwatches include a barometer.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A pressure sensor used for altitude changes, elevation estimates, and weather-related context.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a barometer. 46.5% of smartwatches include a barometer.
Priority:
LOW
Gyroscope
yes
What it is
A motion sensor that measures rotation and helps interpret wrist movement more accurately.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a gyroscope. 28.9% of smartwatches include a gyroscope.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A motion sensor that measures rotation and helps interpret wrist movement more accurately.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a gyroscope. 28.9% of smartwatches include a gyroscope.
Priority:
LOW
Cadence sensor
?
?
Distance tracking
yes
What it is
The ability to measure how far you move during walks, runs, rides, or other activities.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports distance tracking. 3.7% of smartwatches support distance tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
The ability to measure how far you move during walks, runs, rides, or other activities.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports distance tracking. 3.7% of smartwatches support distance tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Step tracking
yes
What it is
Automatic counting of daily steps and similar walking movement.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports step tracking. 0.8% of smartwatches support step tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
Automatic counting of daily steps and similar walking movement.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports step tracking. 0.8% of smartwatches support step tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Pace tracking
yes
What it is
Tracking of current or average pace during activities such as running or cycling.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports pace tracking. 19.5% of smartwatches support pace tracking.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Tracking of current or average pace during activities such as running or cycling.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports pace tracking. 19.5% of smartwatches support pace tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Elevation tracking
yes
What it is
Tracking of climbed, descended, or current elevation during activities.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports elevation tracking. 32.4% of smartwatches support elevation tracking.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Tracking of climbed, descended, or current elevation during activities.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports elevation tracking. 32.4% of smartwatches support elevation tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Route tracker
yes
What it is
Route recording that stores the path taken during an outdoor session.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports route tracking. 23% of smartwatches support route tracking.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Route recording that stores the path taken during an outdoor session.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports route tracking. 23% of smartwatches support route tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Live tracking
yes
What it is
Real-time sharing of your route or location with other people during an activity.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports live tracking. 10.5% of smartwatches support live tracking.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Real-time sharing of your route or location with other people during an activity.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports live tracking. 10.5% of smartwatches support live tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Maximum altitude
?
?
Multi-sport mode
yes
What it is
A training mode designed to handle multiple sports within a single session.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a multi-sport mode. 28.4% of smartwatches include a multi-sport mode.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Fenix 8 supports multi-sport mode.
no
What it is
A training mode designed to handle multiple sports within a single session.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not include a multi-sport mode. 71.8% of smartwatches include a multi-sport mode.
Priority:
LOW
Swim sport mode
yes
What it is
A dedicated workout mode tuned for pool or open-water swimming.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a swim sport mode. 23.1% of smartwatches include a swim sport mode.
Priority:
LOW
?
Exercise tagging
yes
What it is
The ability to label or classify workouts by exercise type.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports exercise tagging. 5.8% of smartwatches support exercise tagging.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
The ability to label or classify workouts by exercise type.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports exercise tagging. 5.8% of smartwatches support exercise tagging.
Priority:
LOW
Number of exercises
?
?
Automatic activity detection
yes
What it is
The ability to recognize certain workouts automatically without manual start.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports automatic activity detection. 18.3% of smartwatches support automatic activity detection.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
The ability to recognize certain workouts automatically without manual start.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports automatic activity detection. 18.3% of smartwatches support automatic activity detection.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Auto pause
yes
What it is
Automatic pausing of workout recording when movement stops.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports auto pause. 37.5% of smartwatches support auto pause.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Automatic pausing of workout recording when movement stops.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports auto pause. 37.5% of smartwatches support auto pause.
Priority:
LOW
Goal setting
yes
What it is
Tools for setting activity, health, or routine targets through the watch ecosystem.
When it matters
When you want extra help staying active or hitting your goals.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports goal setting. 1.9% of smartwatches support goal setting.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Tools for setting activity, health, or routine targets through the watch ecosystem.
When it matters
When you want extra help staying active or hitting your goals.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports goal setting. 1.9% of smartwatches support goal setting.
Priority:
LOW
Coaching
yes
What it is
Guided training or wellness suggestions based on your data and habits.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports coaching. 41.3% of smartwatches support coaching.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Guided training or wellness suggestions based on your data and habits.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports coaching. 41.3% of smartwatches support coaching.
Priority:
LOW
Achievements
yes
What it is
Badges or progress milestones awarded for activity and usage goals.
When it matters
When you want extra help staying active or hitting your goals.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports achievements. 13% of smartwatches support achievements.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Badges or progress milestones awarded for activity and usage goals.
When it matters
When you want extra help staying active or hitting your goals.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports achievements. 13% of smartwatches support achievements.
Priority:
LOW
Route support
yes
What it is
Support for following saved routes, courses, or turn guidance during activities.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports route support. 45.6% of smartwatches support route support.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Support for following saved routes, courses, or turn guidance during activities.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports route support. 45.6% of smartwatches support route support.
Priority:
LOW
Voice feedback
?
yes
What it is
Spoken prompts that report pace, laps, instructions, or other activity updates.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports voice feedback. 36.6% of smartwatches support voice feedback.
Priority:
LOW
Heart rate strap support
yes
What it is
Compatibility with external chest straps or other heart-rate transmitters.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports external heart rate monitor compatibility. 53.5% of smartwatches support external heart rate monitor compatibility.
Priority:
LOW
?
Battery
8.7
6.3
Battery life
16 days
What it is
How many days the watch keeps running on one full charge with typical everyday use, including notifications and background heart-rate tracking.
When it matters
Important for travellers and campers who cannot charge daily, and for anyone who wears sleep tracking and dislikes charging at night.
Garmin Fenix 8 lasts 16 days on a charge, which is longer than 87% of Smartwatches and the same as 1.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=7 days
Priority:
HIGH
Garmin Fenix 8 has the longest battery life.
1 day
What it is
How many days the watch keeps running on one full charge with typical everyday use, including notifications and background heart-rate tracking.
When it matters
Important for travellers and campers who cannot charge daily, and for anyone who wears sleep tracking and dislikes charging at night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm lasts 1 day on a charge, which is shorter than 88.1% of Smartwatches and the same as 8.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=7 days
Priority:
HIGH
Battery life in training mode
47 h
What it is
The number of hours the watch can keep recording a workout with GPS and heart-rate sensors fully active on one charge.
When it matters
Matters for runners, cyclists and hikers who do long sessions of several hours and need the watch to keep recording until the finish.
Garmin Fenix 8 records workouts for 47 h on a charge, which is longer than 88.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=36.8 h
Priority:
MEDIUM
?
Battery life with GPS on
47 h
What it is
How many hours the watch runs with GPS switched on, the biggest drain on battery during outdoor activities.
When it matters
Matters for people who record long routes outdoors, such as trail runs or bike rides, and want to know the watch will last the whole ride.
Garmin Fenix 8 lasts 47 h with GPS on, which is longer than 90.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=35 h
Priority:
MEDIUM
?
Battery power
?
465 mAh
What it is
The capacity of the internal battery, measured in milliamp hours, which sets how much energy the watch can store.
When it matters
Relevant to people who wear the watch around the clock with an always-on display, where a larger cell can mean fewer evening charges, though it adds weight.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a 465 mAh battery, which is larger than 83.8% of Smartwatches and the same as 0.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=397 mAh
Priority:
LOW
Charge time
?
60 min
What it is
How long the watch takes to charge from empty to full using its supplied charger.
When it matters
Useful if you often forget to charge overnight and need a quick top-up before a workout or a day out.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm charges from empty in 60 min, which is quicker than 83.8% of Smartwatches and the same as 12% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=102 min
Priority:
MEDIUM
Wireless charging
no
What it is
Support for recharging the watch through a charging pad, puck, or other cable-free method.
When it matters
When you want to top up the battery quickly.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not support wireless charging. 23.5% of smartwatches support wireless charging.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
Support for recharging the watch through a charging pad, puck, or other cable-free method.
When it matters
When you want to top up the battery quickly.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not support wireless charging. 23.5% of smartwatches support wireless charging.
Priority:
LOW
Low power mode
yes
What it is
A power-saving mode that reduces features or performance to stretch battery life.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a low power mode. 6.9% of smartwatches include a low power mode.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A power-saving mode that reduces features or performance to stretch battery life.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a low power mode. 6.9% of smartwatches include a low power mode.
Priority:
LOW
Solar power battery
no
What it is
Solar-assisted charging that tops up the battery from light exposure.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not support solar charging. 2.4% of smartwatches support solar charging.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
Solar-assisted charging that tops up the battery from light exposure.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not support solar charging. 2.4% of smartwatches support solar charging.
Priority:
LOW
Battery level indicator
yes
What it is
A readout that shows remaining battery charge on the watch or in its app.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a battery level indicator. 2.2% of smartwatches include a battery level indicator.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A readout that shows remaining battery charge on the watch or in its app.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a battery level indicator. 2.2% of smartwatches include a battery level indicator.
Priority:
LOW
Battery type
Li-Po
What it is
The battery chemistry or construction used inside the watch.
When it matters
When battery lifespan or charging habits matter to you.
Garmin Fenix 8 uses a Li-Po battery type which is more advanced than that of 49.7% of smartwatches and the same as that of 50.3% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Fenix 8 uses the most advanced battery type.
Li-ion
What it is
The battery chemistry or construction used inside the watch.
When it matters
When battery lifespan or charging habits matter to you.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm uses a Li-ion battery type which is less advanced than that of 50.4% of smartwatches and the same as that of 46% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Smart features
9.5
9.2
Operating system
Garmin OS
What it is
The software platform the watch runs, which decides which apps, watch faces and phone pairing options you get.
When it matters
When you want third-party apps, a wide range of watch faces, or a watch that pairs with both iPhone and Android.
Garmin Fenix 8 runs Garmin OS, which is more advanced than the system in 70.7% of Smartwatches and equal to 9.2% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Wear OS
What it is
The software platform the watch runs, which decides which apps, watch faces and phone pairing options you get.
When it matters
When you want third-party apps, a wide range of watch faces, or a watch that pairs with both iPhone and Android.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm runs Wear OS, which is more advanced than the system in 80.1% of Smartwatches and equal to 15.8% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm runs the most advanced operating system.
Software update frequency
occasional
What it is
Shows how actively the watch is still updated: regular means ongoing updates throughout active support, occasional means updates every few months or only from time to time, and ended means active software support has mostly stopped.
When it matters
When you care how actively the watch is still supported with fixes, patches, and new features.
Garmin Fenix 8 has occasional software update support which is more active than that of 54% of smartwatches and equal to that of 40.2% of smartwatches.
Priority:
MEDIUM
occasional
What it is
Shows how actively the watch is still updated: regular means ongoing updates throughout active support, occasional means updates every few months or only from time to time, and ended means active software support has mostly stopped.
When it matters
When you care how actively the watch is still supported with fixes, patches, and new features.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has occasional software update support which is more active than that of 54% of smartwatches and equal to that of 40.2% of smartwatches.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Third-party app support
yes
What it is
Support for installing or using apps from developers beyond the watch maker.
When it matters
When you care about apps, features, and long-term support.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports third-party apps. 48.5% of smartwatches support third-party apps.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Support for installing or using apps from developers beyond the watch maker.
When it matters
When you care about apps, features, and long-term support.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports third-party apps. 48.5% of smartwatches support third-party apps.
Priority:
LOW
Notifications
yes
What it is
Mirroring of calls, messages, apps, or other alerts on the watch.
When it matters
When you want to check alerts without taking out your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports notifications. 0.3% of smartwatches support notifications.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Mirroring of calls, messages, apps, or other alerts on the watch.
When it matters
When you want to check alerts without taking out your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports notifications. 0.3% of smartwatches support notifications.
Priority:
LOW
Voice assistant support
yes
What it is
Support for a voice assistant that can answer queries or trigger actions from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports voice assistants. 30.8% of smartwatches support voice assistants.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Support for a voice assistant that can answer queries or trigger actions from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports voice assistants. 30.8% of smartwatches support voice assistants.
Priority:
LOW
Voice commands
yes
What it is
The ability to control functions or start actions using spoken commands.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports voice commands. 31.9% of smartwatches support voice commands.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
The ability to control functions or start actions using spoken commands.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports voice commands. 31.9% of smartwatches support voice commands.
Priority:
LOW
Call control
yes
What it is
The ability to mute, reject, or otherwise manage calls from the watch interface.
When it matters
When you want to handle calls or alerts without taking out your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 offers call control. 8.8% of smartwatches offer call control.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
The ability to mute, reject, or otherwise manage calls from the watch interface.
When it matters
When you want to handle calls or alerts without taking out your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm offers call control. 8.8% of smartwatches offer call control.
Priority:
LOW
Call answering
yes
What it is
The ability to answer an incoming call directly from the watch.
When it matters
When you want to handle calls or alerts without taking out your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports call answering. 40% of smartwatches support call answering.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
The ability to answer an incoming call directly from the watch.
When it matters
When you want to handle calls or alerts without taking out your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports call answering. 40% of smartwatches support call answering.
Priority:
LOW
Music playback
yes
What it is
Playback of music or audio directly from the watch, with or without a phone nearby.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports music playback. 42.9% of smartwatches support music playback.
Priority:
LOW
?
Camera remote control
?
yes
What it is
Remote shutter control that lets the watch trigger a paired camera or phone camera.
When it matters
When you want to control your phone camera from the watch.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes built-in camera remote control. 14.5% of smartwatches that are equipped with a camera include built-in camera remote control.
Priority:
LOW
Calendar sync
yes
What it is
Synchronization of calendar events and schedules between the watch and connected services.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports calendar sync. 4.7% of smartwatches support calendar sync.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Synchronization of calendar events and schedules between the watch and connected services.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports calendar sync. 4.7% of smartwatches support calendar sync.
Priority:
LOW
Widget support
yes
What it is
Support for small glanceable panels that show live information or quick actions.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports widgets. 15.6% of smartwatches support widgets.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Support for small glanceable panels that show live information or quick actions.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports widgets. 15.6% of smartwatches support widgets.
Priority:
LOW
Personalization
yes
What it is
Options for customizing watch faces, layouts, shortcuts, or interface style.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports personalization. 1% of smartwatches support personalization.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Options for customizing watch faces, layouts, shortcuts, or interface style.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports personalization. 1% of smartwatches support personalization.
Priority:
LOW
Phone finder
yes
What it is
A feature that helps locate your phone from the watch by triggering alerts or pings.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes phone finder. 3.6% of smartwatches include phone finder.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A feature that helps locate your phone from the watch by triggering alerts or pings.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes phone finder. 3.6% of smartwatches include phone finder.
Priority:
LOW
Passcode
yes
What it is
A lock code or PIN that protects access to the watch and its data.
When it matters
When you want the watch to fit your needs more closely.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes passcode protection. 29.6% of smartwatches include passcode protection.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A lock code or PIN that protects access to the watch and its data.
When it matters
When you want the watch to fit your needs more closely.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes passcode protection. 29.6% of smartwatches include passcode protection.
Priority:
LOW
Gesture control
yes
What it is
Control of watch functions through wrist movements, taps, or hand gestures.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports gesture control. 20.4% of smartwatches support gesture control.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Control of watch functions through wrist movements, taps, or hand gestures.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports gesture control. 20.4% of smartwatches support gesture control.
Priority:
LOW
Stopwatch
yes
What it is
A timer tool for measuring elapsed time directly from the watch.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a stopwatch. 1% of smartwatches include a stopwatch.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A timer tool for measuring elapsed time directly from the watch.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a stopwatch. 1% of smartwatches include a stopwatch.
Priority:
LOW
Smart alarm
no
What it is
A smart alarm tries to wake you during a lighter sleep phase within a chosen time window instead of at one fixed minute.
When it matters
It matters if you wear your smartwatch overnight and want a gentler wake-up based on your sleep pattern rather than a standard fixed alarm.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not support a smart alarm. 50.7% of smartwatches support this feature.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A smart alarm tries to wake you during a lighter sleep phase within a chosen time window instead of at one fixed minute.
When it matters
It matters if you wear your smartwatch overnight and want a gentler wake-up based on your sleep pattern rather than a standard fixed alarm.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not support a smart alarm. 50.7% of smartwatches support this feature.
Priority:
LOW
Silent alarm
yes
What it is
Alarm functionality that wakes or alerts you through vibration instead of sound.
When it matters
When you want alerts that stay discreet.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports silent alarms. 0.6% of smartwatches support silent alarms.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Alarm functionality that wakes or alerts you through vibration instead of sound.
When it matters
When you want alerts that stay discreet.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports silent alarms. 0.6% of smartwatches support silent alarms.
Priority:
LOW
Vibrating alerts
yes
What it is
Haptic alerts for notifications, calls, timers, and other on-wrist prompts.
When it matters
When you want alerts that stay discreet.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports vibrating alerts. 0.5% of smartwatches support vibrating alerts.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Haptic alerts for notifications, calls, timers, and other on-wrist prompts.
When it matters
When you want alerts that stay discreet.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports vibrating alerts. 0.5% of smartwatches support vibrating alerts.
Priority:
LOW
Emergency SOS
yes
What it is
An emergency feature that can contact help or alert trusted people from the watch.
When it matters
When you want extra help in an emergency.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes Emergency SOS. 55.3% of smartwatches include Emergency SOS.
Priority:
LOW
?
Fall detection
?
?
Crash detection
yes
What it is
Detection of severe impacts or crashes that can trigger emergency workflows.
When it matters
When you want extra help in an emergency.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports crash detection. 86.1% of smartwatches support crash detection.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Detection of severe impacts or crashes that can trigger emergency workflows.
When it matters
When you want extra help in an emergency.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports crash detection. 86.1% of smartwatches support crash detection.
Priority:
LOW
Connectivity
8.7
8.8
Cellular module
no
What it is
Built-in mobile connectivity that can keep the watch online away from the phone.
When it matters
When you want calls, messages, or data without your phone nearby.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not include a cellular module. 16.7% of smartwatches include a cellular module.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Built-in mobile connectivity that can keep the watch online away from the phone.
When it matters
When you want calls, messages, or data without your phone nearby.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a cellular module. 83.5% of smartwatches include a cellular module.
Priority:
LOW
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a cellular module.
SIM cards
0
What it is
The number or type of SIM options the watch accepts for cellular service.
When it matters
When you want calls, messages, or data without your phone nearby.
Good value:
🎯 eSIM support
Priority:
LOW
?
GPS
yes
What it is
Built-in satellite positioning that lets the watch record location during outdoor activity.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports GPS. 40.3% of smartwatches support GPS.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
Built-in satellite positioning that lets the watch record location during outdoor activity.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports GPS. 40.3% of smartwatches support GPS.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Galileo support
yes
What it is
Support for Galileo satellites alongside other positioning systems.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports Galileo navigation. 56.5% of smartwatches support Galileo navigation.
Priority:
LOW
?
Dual-frequency GPS
yes
What it is
Whether the watch receives two satellite frequency bands at once, which improves location accuracy near tall buildings and under tree cover.
When it matters
Matters for runners and hikers who record routes in cities or forests, where single-band signals often drift or lose the track.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports dual-frequency GPS. 85% of Smartwatches offer this.
Priority:
LOW
?
Compass
yes
What it is
A directional sensor that helps the watch determine heading and orientation.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a compass. 43.4% of smartwatches include a compass.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A directional sensor that helps the watch determine heading and orientation.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a compass. 43.4% of smartwatches include a compass.
Priority:
LOW
Maps support
yes
What it is
The ability to view maps, navigation guidance, or route layouts on the watch.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports maps. 65.7% of smartwatches support maps.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
The ability to view maps, navigation guidance, or route layouts on the watch.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports maps. 65.7% of smartwatches support maps.
Priority:
LOW
NFC
yes
What it is
Near-field communication hardware used for payments, pairing, or quick tap-based actions.
When it matters
When you want to pay quickly or pair devices with a tap.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports NFC. 54.9% of smartwatches support NFC.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Near-field communication hardware used for payments, pairing, or quick tap-based actions.
When it matters
When you want to pay quickly or pair devices with a tap.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports NFC. 54.9% of smartwatches support NFC.
Priority:
LOW
UWB chip
no
What it is
UWB is an ultra-wideband radio chip used for precise nearby device location and secure short-range interactions.
When it matters
When you want precise finding features, nearby device awareness, or advanced ecosystem features such as directional locating.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not include a UWB chip. 2.3% of smartwatches include UWB.
Good value:
🎯 yes
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
UWB is an ultra-wideband radio chip used for precise nearby device location and secure short-range interactions.
When it matters
When you want precise finding features, nearby device awareness, or advanced ecosystem features such as directional locating.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a UWB chip. 97.8% of smartwatches include UWB.
Good value:
🎯 yes
Priority:
LOW
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a UWB chip.
Bluetooth version
5.2
What it is
The Bluetooth standard the watch uses to pair with your phone, earbuds and sensors, with newer versions generally offering better range and efficiency.
When it matters
Matters if you pair wireless earbuds, heart-rate straps or cycling sensors, since older versions may connect less reliably with newer accessories.
Garmin Fenix 8 uses Bluetooth 5.2, which is more current than 69% of Smartwatches and the same as 15.2% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=5.1
Priority:
LOW
6.0
What it is
The Bluetooth standard the watch uses to pair with your phone, earbuds and sensors, with newer versions generally offering better range and efficiency.
When it matters
Matters if you pair wireless earbuds, heart-rate straps or cycling sensors, since older versions may connect less reliably with newer accessories.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm uses Bluetooth 6, which is more current than 98.7% of Smartwatches and the same as 1.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=5.1
Priority:
LOW
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has the most current Bluetooth version.
Wi-Fi support
yes
What it is
Built-in Wi-Fi that lets the watch connect to wireless networks directly.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work smoothly with your phone and accessories.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports Wi-Fi. 56.6% of smartwatches support Wi-Fi.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Built-in Wi-Fi that lets the watch connect to wireless networks directly.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work smoothly with your phone and accessories.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm supports Wi-Fi. 56.6% of smartwatches support Wi-Fi.
Priority:
LOW
Wi-Fi version
?
Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax)
What it is
The Wi-Fi standard the watch supports for connecting directly to a home network, if it has Wi-Fi at all.
When it matters
Helpful when you want music downloads, app updates or watch-face syncing without your phone nearby, as long as your home router supports the same standard.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm uses Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax), which is more advanced than 98.8% of Smartwatches and the same as 1.2% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
ANT+ support
yes
What it is
Support for ANT+ accessories such as heart-rate straps, bike sensors, and gym equipment.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Garmin Fenix 8 supports ANT+. 87.1% of smartwatches support ANT+.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Fenix 8 supports ANT+.
no
What it is
Support for ANT+ accessories such as heart-rate straps, bike sensors, and gym equipment.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not support ANT+. 13% of smartwatches support ANT+.
Priority:
LOW
iOS compatibility
yes
What it is
Whether the watch can pair with and receive notifications from an iPhone running Apple's iOS.
When it matters
Essential for iPhone owners, since a watch that cannot pair will not show calls, messages or fitness data on the phone.
Garmin Fenix 8 works with iOS devices. 5.4% of Smartwatches offer this.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Fenix 8 works with iOS devices.
no
What it is
Whether the watch can pair with and receive notifications from an iPhone running Apple's iOS.
When it matters
Essential for iPhone owners, since a watch that cannot pair will not show calls, messages or fitness data on the phone.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not work with iOS devices. 94.7% of Smartwatches offer this.
Priority:
LOW
Android compatibility
yes
What it is
Shows how well the smartwatch works with Android pairing, syncing, and core features.
When it matters
When you use an Android phone and want the watch to pair, sync, and keep its main features working properly.
Garmin Fenix 8 is compatible with Android. 4.3% of smartwatches are compatible with Android.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Shows how well the smartwatch works with Android pairing, syncing, and core features.
When it matters
When you use an Android phone and want the watch to pair, sync, and keep its main features working properly.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is compatible with Android. 4.3% of smartwatches are compatible with Android.
Priority:
LOW
Display & Design
7.9
8.9
Screen size
1.3 inch
What it is
The diagonal size of the display in inches, measured across the active screen area.
When it matters
Matters if you read long messages, follow maps or check detailed workout graphs often, though bigger screens add bulk on small wrists.
Garmin Fenix 8 has a 1.3 inch screen, which is smaller than 67.1% of Smartwatches and the same as 10.8% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=1.5 inch
Priority:
LOW
1.4 inch
What it is
The diagonal size of the display in inches, measured across the active screen area.
When it matters
Matters if you read long messages, follow maps or check detailed workout graphs often, though bigger screens add bulk on small wrists.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a 1.4 inch screen, which is larger than 48.9% of Smartwatches and the same as 6.7% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=1.5 inch
Priority:
LOW
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has the largest screen.
Display type
AMOLED
What it is
The screen technology used, which affects colour richness, contrast, outdoor readability and battery use.
When it matters
When you check the watch face in bright sunlight outdoors or want a dark, always-on display at night.
Garmin Fenix 8 uses AMOLED, which is more advanced than the screen in 46.9% of Smartwatches and equal to 53.1% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
AMOLED
What it is
The screen technology used, which affects colour richness, contrast, outdoor readability and battery use.
When it matters
When you check the watch face in bright sunlight outdoors or want a dark, always-on display at night.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm uses AMOLED, which is more advanced than the screen in 46.9% of Smartwatches and equal to 53.1% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Resolution
454x 454
What it is
The total number of pixels available on the watch display.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Garmin Fenix 8 has a display resolution of 454x454 which is higher than that of 76.5% of smartwatches and equal to that of 7% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=416 x 416
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Fenix 8 has the highest screen resolution.
448x 448
What it is
The total number of pixels available on the watch display.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a display resolution of 448x448 which is higher than that of 75.4% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=416 x 416
Priority:
LOW
Pixel density
453 ppi
What it is
How many pixels are packed into each inch of the screen, which determines how crisp text and icons look.
When it matters
When you read short messages, map directions or small fitness figures at a glance.
Garmin Fenix 8 has a pixel density of 453 ppi, which is higher than 75.6% of Smartwatches and equal to 2.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=326 ppi
Priority:
LOW
453 ppi
What it is
How many pixels are packed into each inch of the screen, which determines how crisp text and icons look.
When it matters
When you read short messages, map directions or small fitness figures at a glance.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a pixel density of 453 ppi, which is higher than 75.6% of Smartwatches and equal to 2.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=326 ppi
Priority:
LOW
Display brightness
1,000 nit
What it is
The peak brightness of the screen, measured in nits, which determines how easily it can be read in direct sunlight.
When it matters
When you run or cycle outdoors on sunny days and need the screen readable without shading it with your hand.
Garmin Fenix 8 has a screen brightness of 1,000 nits, which is higher than 53.5% of Smartwatches and equal to 27% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=1000 nits
Priority:
LOW
3,000 nits
What it is
The peak brightness of the screen, measured in nits, which determines how easily it can be read in direct sunlight.
When it matters
When you run or cycle outdoors on sunny days and need the screen readable without shading it with your hand.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a screen brightness of 3,000 nits, which is higher than 93.2% of Smartwatches and equal to 6.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=1000 nits
Priority:
LOW
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has the brightest screen.
Always-On Display
yes
What it is
A display mode that keeps key information visible even when the watch is idle.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Garmin Fenix 8 has an always-on display. 29.7% of smartwatches have an always-on display.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A display mode that keeps key information visible even when the watch is idle.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has an always-on display. 29.7% of smartwatches have an always-on display.
Priority:
LOW
Touch screen
yes
What it is
Direct touch input on the display for navigating menus, apps, and quick controls.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Garmin Fenix 8 has a touch screen. 8.5% of smartwatches have a touch screen.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Direct touch input on the display for navigating menus, apps, and quick controls.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a touch screen. 8.5% of smartwatches have a touch screen.
Priority:
LOW
Ambient light sensor
yes
What it is
A sensor that detects surrounding light to adjust screen behavior or brightness.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes an ambient light sensor. 36.6% of smartwatches include an ambient light sensor.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A sensor that detects surrounding light to adjust screen behavior or brightness.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes an ambient light sensor. 36.6% of smartwatches include an ambient light sensor.
Priority:
LOW
Display glass type
?
Corning Gorilla Glass 5
What it is
The glass material or protective cover used over the display.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm uses Corning Gorilla Glass 5 display glass which is more durable than that of 75.6% of smartwatches and the same as that of 0.9% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 Sapphire or Gorilla Glass
Priority:
LOW
IP rating
IP68
What it is
The ingress protection code that shows how well the case keeps out dust and water.
When it matters
When you swim, shower with the watch on, or train in heavy rain and sweat, where water can get past seals.
Garmin Fenix 8 is rated IP68, which is better sealed than 33.8% of Smartwatches and equal to 61.9% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 IP68 or better
Priority:
LOW
IP68
What it is
The ingress protection code that shows how well the case keeps out dust and water.
When it matters
When you swim, shower with the watch on, or train in heavy rain and sweat, where water can get past seals.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is rated IP68, which is better sealed than 33.8% of Smartwatches and equal to 61.9% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 IP68 or better
Priority:
LOW
Waterproof depth rating
100 m
What it is
The maximum depth in metres the watch is rated to be submerged in still water without leaking.
When it matters
When you swim in a pool or open water, or dive or snorkel with the watch on your wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 is rated to 100 m, which is deeper than 91.8% of Smartwatches and equal to 7.9% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=50 m
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Fenix 8 has the deepest water rating.
50 m
What it is
The maximum depth in metres the watch is rated to be submerged in still water without leaking.
When it matters
When you swim in a pool or open water, or dive or snorkel with the watch on your wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is rated to 50 m, which is deeper than 43.4% of Smartwatches and equal to 48.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=50 m
Priority:
LOW
Rugged design
yes
What it is
A build style aimed at tougher environments, impacts, and harsher outdoor use.
When it matters
When you wear the watch in rain, sweat, or water.
Garmin Fenix 8 has a rugged design. 58.9% of smartwatches have a rugged design.
Priority:
LOW
?
Weight
59.0 g
What it is
The mass of the complete watch including case, strap and battery, measured in grams.
When it matters
When you wear it to bed for sleep tracking or all day, since extra grams add up on a smaller wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 weighs 59 g, which is heavier than 74.6% of Smartwatches and equal to 0.7% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=37 g
Priority:
LOW
36.7 g
What it is
The mass of the complete watch including case, strap and battery, measured in grams.
When it matters
When you wear it to bed for sleep tracking or all day, since extra grams add up on a smaller wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm weighs 36.7 g, which is lighter than 71% of Smartwatches and equal to 0.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=37 g
Priority:
LOW
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is the lightest.
Thickness
13.8 mm
What it is
The depth of the case from the back to the top of the glass, which determines how much it protrudes from the wrist.
When it matters
When you wear it under a shirt cuff or a jacket sleeve, where a thick case snags and sits awkwardly.
Garmin Fenix 8 is 13.8 mm thick, which is thicker than 87.4% of Smartwatches and equal to 0.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=10.9 mm
Priority:
LOW
12.3 mm
What it is
The depth of the case from the back to the top of the glass, which determines how much it protrudes from the wrist.
When it matters
When you wear it under a shirt cuff or a jacket sleeve, where a thick case snags and sits awkwardly.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is 12.3 mm thick, which is thicker than 65.5% of Smartwatches and equal to 1.6% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=10.9 mm
Priority:
LOW
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has the slimmest case.
Height
43 mm
What it is
The vertical size of the case from top to bottom, which sets how much of the wrist the watch covers.
When it matters
When you have a narrow wrist or wear the watch under a sleeve, where a tall case can feel bulky.
Garmin Fenix 8 is 43 mm tall, which is shorter than 67.4% of Smartwatches and equal to 3.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=12.6 mm
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Fenix 8 has the shortest case.
45 mm
What it is
The vertical size of the case from top to bottom, which sets how much of the wrist the watch covers.
When it matters
When you have a narrow wrist or wear the watch under a sleeve, where a tall case can feel bulky.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm is 45 mm tall, which is shorter than 49.2% of Smartwatches and equal to 5.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=12.6 mm
Priority:
LOW
Width
43 mm
What it is
The side-to-side size of the case, measured across the widest part of the watch face.
When it matters
When you have a small wrist or want a watch that does not overhang the edges of the wrist.
Garmin Fenix 8 measures 43 mm, which is wider than 51.9% of Smartwatches and equal to 2.7% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=39 mm
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Fenix 8 has the narrowest case.
45 mm
What it is
The side-to-side size of the case, measured across the widest part of the watch face.
When it matters
When you have a small wrist or want a watch that does not overhang the edges of the wrist.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm measures 45 mm, which is wider than 64.3% of Smartwatches and equal to 6.5% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=39 mm
Priority:
LOW
Width of band
22 mm
What it is
The width of the strap where it meets the case, which changes both the look and how the strap feels on the wrist.
When it matters
When you choose a replacement strap, since band width decides which aftermarket straps and quick-release pins will fit.
Garmin Fenix 8 has a 22 mm strap, which is narrower than 8.4% of Smartwatches and equal to 57.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 18-22 mm
Priority:
LOW
?
Case material
fiber-reinforced polymer, metal
What it is
The main material used for the watch case.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Fenix 8 uses fiber-reinforced polymer, metal for the case material which is less premium than that of 71% of smartwatches and the same as that of 0.3% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 Aluminium, stainless steel, or titanium
Priority:
LOW
?
Band material
silicone
What it is
The main material used for the watch strap or band.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Fenix 8 uses silicone for the band material which is more premium than that of 9.9% of smartwatches and the same as that of 53.9% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
?
Replaceable band
yes
What it is
A strap system that can be detached and swapped for a different compatible band.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a replaceable band. 1.2% of smartwatches include a replaceable band.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A strap system that can be detached and swapped for a different compatible band.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a replaceable band. 1.2% of smartwatches include a replaceable band.
Priority:
LOW
Form
round
What it is
The overall design form, such as round, square, or another case shape.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Fenix 8 uses a round watch form which is more practical than that of 37.3% of smartwatches and the same as that of 62.7% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
round
What it is
The overall design form, such as round, square, or another case shape.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm uses a round watch form which is more practical than that of 37.3% of smartwatches and the same as that of 62.7% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Hybrid design
no
What it is
A watch design that mixes smart features with traditional analog or low-power elements.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not have a hybrid design. 8.6% of smartwatches have a hybrid design.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A watch design that mixes smart features with traditional analog or low-power elements.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not have a hybrid design. 8.6% of smartwatches have a hybrid design.
Priority:
LOW
Kid-friendly design
?
no
What it is
A child-oriented design focused on smaller wrists, simpler controls, or safer materials.
When it matters
When the watch is for a child and daily comfort matters.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not have a kid-friendly design. 1.5% of smartwatches have a kid-friendly design.
Priority:
LOW
Maximum operating temperature
?
?
Minimum operating temperature
?
?
Hardware
8.4
8.4
CPU speed
?
?
Processor model
?
Snapdragon W5 Gen 2
What it is
The processor model is the chipset or SoC that powers the watch's performance, connectivity, and efficiency.
When it matters
When you care about app responsiveness, platform generation, and long-term feature support.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm uses the Snapdragon W5 Gen 2 processor model.
Good value:
🎯 modern smartwatch chipset
Priority:
LOW
RAM
?
2 GB
What it is
The working memory the watch uses to run apps, watch faces and background tasks at the same time.
When it matters
When you want to run several third-party apps, store offline music, or keep the watch responsive after months of software updates.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has 2 GB of RAM, which is more than 76.4% of Smartwatches and equal to 22.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=1 GB
Priority:
LOW
Internal storage
32 GB
What it is
The built-in flash memory where the watch keeps apps, music, photos and watch faces.
When it matters
When you want to load offline playlists for a run or keep maps and several apps on the watch so you can leave the phone at home.
Garmin Fenix 8 has 32 GB of internal storage, which is more than 81.3% of Smartwatches and equal to 15% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=8 GB
Priority:
LOW
64 GB
What it is
The built-in flash memory where the watch keeps apps, music, photos and watch faces.
When it matters
When you want to load offline playlists for a run or keep maps and several apps on the watch so you can leave the phone at home.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has 64 GB of internal storage, which is more than 96.5% of Smartwatches and equal to 3.5% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=8 GB
Priority:
LOW
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has the most internal storage.
External memory slot
no
What it is
A slot for expandable storage such as a memory card, if the watch provides one.
When it matters
When you want more room for apps, music, or offline data.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not include an external memory slot. 0.3% of smartwatches include an external memory slot.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A slot for expandable storage such as a memory card, if the watch provides one.
When it matters
When you want more room for apps, music, or offline data.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not include an external memory slot. 0.3% of smartwatches include an external memory slot.
Priority:
LOW
Camera
no
What it is
Whether the watch includes a camera for photos, video, or calling.
When it matters
When you want to take photos or video calls from the watch itself.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not include a camera. 1.8% of smartwatches include a camera.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
Whether the watch includes a camera for photos, video, or calling.
When it matters
When you want to take photos or video calls from the watch itself.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not include a camera. 1.8% of smartwatches include a camera.
Priority:
LOW
Camera megapixels
N/A
N/A
Built-in speaker
yes
What it is
An onboard speaker for calls, prompts, alarms, or media playback.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Garmin Fenix 8 includes a built-in speaker. 43.4% of smartwatches include a built-in speaker.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
An onboard speaker for calls, prompts, alarms, or media playback.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm includes a built-in speaker. 43.4% of smartwatches include a built-in speaker.
Priority:
LOW
Number of microphones
1
What it is
How many microphones the watch uses to pick up your voice for calls, dictation and voice commands.
When it matters
When you take calls on the watch on a noisy street or dictate messages while running, where extra microphones help filter out wind and traffic.
Garmin Fenix 8 has a microphone count of 1, which is more than 27.1% of Smartwatches and equal to 67.5% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=2
Priority:
LOW
1
What it is
How many microphones the watch uses to pick up your voice for calls, dictation and voice commands.
When it matters
When you take calls on the watch on a noisy street or dictate messages while running, where extra microphones help filter out wind and traffic.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm has a microphone count of 1, which is more than 27.1% of Smartwatches and equal to 67.5% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=2
Priority:
LOW
3.5 mm audio jack
no
What it is
A standard headphone jack for wired audio accessories.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Garmin Fenix 8 does not include a 3.5 mm audio jack. 0.5% of smartwatches include a 3.5 mm audio jack.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A standard headphone jack for wired audio accessories.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm does not include a 3.5 mm audio jack. 0.5% of smartwatches include a 3.5 mm audio jack.
Priority:
LOW

Best alternatives to the Garmin Fenix 8 and the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm

Other models worth a look, with one reason each against the Garmin Fenix 8 and Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm.

Garmin Fenix 8 vs Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm: questions people ask

Which is better, the Garmin Fenix 8 or the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm?

The Garmin Fenix 8 scores 9.1 overall against 8.8 for the Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm.

Which is better for sleep tracking?

The Garmin Fenix 8: 10 against 8.2 out of 10 on our sleep tracking score.

Comparison of Garmin Fenix 8 and Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm with other products

1Product to compare no. 1
VS
2Product to compare no. 2
VS
3Product to compare no. 3 (optional)

Graphical comparison of Garmin Fenix 8 and Google Pixel Watch 5 45mm with all other products

No results found