Apple Watch Series 4 40mm vs Garmin Vivoactive 5

*As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Garmin Vivoactive 5 wins

  • The Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a higher overall score than the Apple Watch Series 4 40mm with us (8.1 vs 7.9). No reviewer has compared these two side by side yet.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Overall score7.9/ 10
from £160
VS
Garmin Vivoactive 5 wins by 0.2
In more best-of lists
WinnerGarmin Vivoactive 5
Overall score8.1/ 10
from £180

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm vs Garmin Vivoactive 5: video reviews

Reviews worth watching before you buy. A video loads only when you press play.

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm8

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is a clear upgrade and easy to recommend, mainly for its speed, battery life and larger display.

  • Much faster than the original and Series 1 and 2
  • Larger edge-to-edge display is easier to use
  • Stainless steel body picks up scratches and scuffs

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is clearly recommended for workouts and everyday use, and the cheaper aluminium versions are fair value.

  • Battery lasts about two days with daily use
  • Stainless steel case shows no scratches after six months
  • Battery life will degrade over the years

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is strongly recommended; once you use its features, you will not want to go without one.

  • Accurate distance tracking on walks
  • Activity rings and sharing keep you motivated

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm impressed after three months as the most powerful Apple Watch yet, though the price is steep.

  • Battery outlasts the advertised 18 hours
  • Interchangeable bands and many watch face options
  • Starting price is high, especially for the LTE model

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is the best smartwatch on the market, with iOS-only compatibility as its only real downside.

  • Much faster performance than the original model
  • Infographic watch face shows more information
  • Works only with iOS and needs an iPhone

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is the biggest upgrade yet, a much faster, bigger-screened watch that finally feels finished despite the higher price.

  • Bigger display makes taps and text easier
  • Much faster processor makes scrolling feel smooth
  • The price increase is hard to ignore

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is the biggest upgrade yet and the best smartwatch by far, especially for iPhone owners.

  • Much bigger screen in a nearly same-size body
  • Louder speaker that helps with calls and Siri
  • No sleep tracking despite its health and fitness focus

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is still excellent in 2024 and worth buying cheaply if the battery health is good.

  • Holds up well after several years of use
  • Music and GPS run tracking without the phone
  • Battery health degrades and often needs replacing
Garmin Vivoactive 58

Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a lot of features for the price, though it feels cheap and lacks some sensors.

  • Broad feature set for the price
  • Comfortable, light design for everyday wear
  • Plastic buttons feel gummy and sometimes need multiple presses

Garmin Vivoactive 5 is hard to recommend over the Venu 3, as its performance does not justify choosing it.

  • Good GPS consistency for a cheaper Garmin model
  • Lower price than the Venu 3
  • Smaller screen than the Venu 3

Garmin Vivoactive 5 has strong health tracking and battery life, so it suits buyers who put fitness ahead of smart features.

  • Lightweight, comfortable design for everyday wear
  • Bright AMOLED display that stays visible in sunlight
  • No built-in speaker or microphone for calls

Garmin Vivoactive 5 is well liked overall, though notifications, sleep mode and activity tracking still need sorting out.

  • Clear AMOLED display with adjustable watch faces
  • Useful health data including heart rate, body battery and sleep score
  • Do-not-disturb and call or text settings are still confusing to set up

Garmin Vivoactive 5 is a good watch for most people, though it is less durable than a rugged model.

  • Accurate strength workout and run tracking
  • Spotify playback directly on the watch without the phone
  • Less durable than the rugged Instinct model

Garmin Vivoactive 5 is not perfect, but it is a good beginner watch with accurate step counting and GPS tracking.

  • Accurate step counter
  • Fast and accurate GPS tracking
  • No temperature sensor

Garmin Vivoactive 5 offers many features and a good design for the price and is among the better budget sports watches right now.

  • Long list of features for the price
  • Light design suited to everyday wear
  • Heart rate less reliable during strength training

Garmin Vivoactive 5 offers good value and a worthwhile update over the Vivoactive 4, though some features were removed.

  • Vivid AMOLED touchscreen display
  • Good GPS performance in the first runs
  • Some sensors and features dropped compared with the Vivoactive 4

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm vs Garmin Vivoactive 5: written reviews

Tests of each product by expert websites, with what they liked and missed.

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm10
tomsguide.com9.0 / 10
  • Screen more than 30% larger, with bigger icons that are easier to read
  • Raise to Speak lets you talk to Siri just by lifting your wrist
  • The 40mm case, 2mm bigger than the old 38mm, felt too big at first
techradar.com9.0 / 10
  • Larger display with rounded edges, giving more room for information; Digital Crown gives haptic clicks as you scroll through lists
  • Louder speaker than before
  • Needs charging once a day, so fall detection could fail if the watch runs flat; Battery lasts under two days, which limits sleep tracking
  • Screen runs edge to edge, reaching 1,000 nits for reading in sunlight
  • Infograph face shows up to eight complications at once
  • No always-on display, so you have to raise your wrist to see the time
  • 44mm screen is more than 30% larger than the old model, easier to read and tap; Crown clicks with haptic feedback, so scrolling feels precise
  • Weekly activity challenges against friends who share their data
  • Heavier than before: 44mm aluminium 36.7g, stainless 47.9g
cyclist.co.uk8.0 / 10
  • GPS tracks rides without a phone, logging kilometre splits and heart rate; Detects runs and walks, offering to record them from when movement began
  • Bright screen and a processor twice as fast as Series 3, with no lag
  • Won't pair with power meters, so no cycling power data
  • Bigger screen fits more on watch faces, so you tap less
  • Louder speaker and relocated microphone make calls clearer
  • Battery hasn't improved, about a day and a half per charge, which limits trips away from home; Still needs its own charger, so it can't charge on a wireless phone pad
  • Touchscreen responds with almost no delay, plus the crown and two buttons
  • Step count was off by only 11 to 34 steps on a mile-long walk
  • No always-on screen or automatic brightness, so you have to wake it to see the time; Touchscreen may be unreliable while submerged
  • Rounded corners and a flatter body sit more comfortably on the wrist
  • Gold stainless steel is the first gold Apple Watch anyone can buy; Gold model suits casual wear through to a blazer and dress pants, with a gold Milanese loop; Recessed dock button and new ceramic underside look more like a watch than a gadget
  • White sport band looks geeky next to the gold finish
  • Automatic workout detection asks to log a session you started without pressing anything
  • Calls are clear with no echo, and Apple says the speaker is 50% louder
  • Walkie Talkie needed a four-minute wait to connect, then dropped after a few minutes
mac4ever.comin French8.0 / 10
  • Digital crown gives a small vibration at each step, like a mechanical click
  • Startup takes 43 seconds, down from 1 minute 30 seconds on Series 3, and apps open almost instantly
  • Existing watch faces were simply scaled up rather than redesigned for the bigger screen
Garmin Vivoactive 59
  • Up to 11 days of battery on one charge
  • Nap tracking, female health tracking and guided meditation
  • No microphone, so no calls from the wrist
  • Stress tracking spotted an oncoming fever before any symptoms appeared
  • Bright, colorful AMOLED screen on par with the Galaxy Watch 4 Classic
  • Running screens use plain white text rather than the AMOLED's colors
  • Charged about every three days, even with the always-on display
  • After one calibration run, distance was within 0.02 miles of the treadmill
  • Can't make calls or reply to texts on the watch
runmorph.comin German8.0 / 10
  • 11-day battery held up in mixed use with several GPS runs
  • Health suite with Body Battery, overnight HRV, sleep and stress tracking
  • No barometric altimeter, so mountain elevation gain is inaccurate
horloge-du-coureur.frin French7.6 / 10
  • Light at 36g with strap, barely noticed even when worn to sleep
  • Heart rate within 1–2 bpm of a chest strap, even on fast interval sessions
  • No barometric altimeter, which limits advanced outdoor use
hrdlpn.nlin Dutch
  • Wrist heart rate, SpO2 and VO2 max built in
  • Round watch with a bright 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen
  • Looks less feminine than the Garmin Lily 2
fitnesshero.frin French
  • Up to 11 days in watch mode, so you rarely think about charging
  • Counts 15–20% more steps than a phone, for more accurate daily activity
  • Screen is less bright in full sun
gymstreet.frin French
  • Soft silicone strap that is barely felt on the wrist day and night
  • Garmin Pay, so you can leave the wallet at home on a run
  • 42mm case may look small on larger wrists
  • Up to 11 days in normal use, or 21 days in power-saving mode
  • Pulse oximeter for oxygen levels, useful while acclimatizing to altitude
  • Always-on screen cuts battery life from 11 days to 5; GPS with music drains the battery in about 8 hours; Charges only with Garmin's own cable, not a universal USB one

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm vs Garmin Vivoactive 5: direct comparison

The radar shows each spec group. Next to it: only the specs that differ, the better value ticked. Open a row for the explanation.

246810HealthFitnessBatterySmart featuresConnectivityDisplay & DesignHardware
Apple Watch Series 4 40mmGarmin Vivoactive 5
Display & Design: Garmin Vivoactive 5 wins 9 of 15 · 7.9 vs 6.7
15 differences✓ = better value
Display typeOLEDAMOLED▶
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses a more advanced screen than Apple Watch Series 4 40mm (AMOLED vs OLED).What it is: The screen technology used, which affects colour richness, contrast, outdoor readability and battery use.When it matters: When you check the watch face in bright sunlight outdoors or want a dark, always-on display at night.
Always-On Displaynoyes▶
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has an always-on display, Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not. 70.3% of smartwatches have an always-on display.What it is: A display mode that keeps key information visible even when the watch is idle.When it matters: When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Display glass typeIon-XCorning Gorilla Glass 3▶
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses Corning Gorilla Glass 3 display glass, while Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses Ion-X.What it is: The glass material or protective cover used over the display.When it matters: When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Screen size1.57 inch1.2 inch▶
The Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has 1.57 inch, the Garmin Vivoactive 5 1.2 inch. That's larger than 74% of smartwatches.What it is: The diagonal size of the display in inches, measured across the active screen area.When it matters: Matters if you read long messages, follow maps or check detailed workout graphs often, though bigger screens add bulk on small wrists.
Weight30.1 g36 g▶
The Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has 30.1 g, the Garmin Vivoactive 5 36 g. That's lighter than 88% of smartwatches.What it is: The mass of the complete watch including case, strap and battery, measured in grams.When it matters: When you wear it to bed for sleep tracking or all day, since extra grams add up on a smaller wrist.
Release date20182023▶
The Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has 2018, the Garmin Vivoactive 5 2023. That's lower than 81% of smartwatches.What it is: The year the watch model was first released, which hints at how modern its chipset, sensors and operating system are.When it matters: Matters most when buying a discounted or second-hand model, since older releases tend to lose software and app updates sooner.
Pixel density325 ppi460 ppi▶
The Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has 325 ppi, the Garmin Vivoactive 5 460 ppi. That's lower than 55% of smartwatches.What it is: How many pixels are packed into each inch of the screen, which determines how crisp text and icons look.When it matters: When you read short messages, map directions or small fitness figures at a glance.
Thickness10.7 mm11.1 mm▶
The Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has 10.7 mm, the Garmin Vivoactive 5 11.1 mm. That's thinner than 76% of smartwatches.What it is: The depth of the case from the back to the top of the glass, which determines how much it protrudes from the wrist.When it matters: When you wear it under a shirt cuff or a jacket sleeve, where a thick case snags and sits awkwardly.
6wins for Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
9wins for Garmin Vivoactive 5

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm vs Garmin Vivoactive 5 in best-of listsA best-of list is an article such as “Best smartwatches” by a test site, a magazine or a YouTube reviewer. We count every list that includes the product and the rank it got there. “#1 or award” means it is ranked first or named the best in a category. Best-of lists make up 30% of the overall score.

Ranks in independent best-of lists from test sites, magazines and YouTube. Click a list to open it.

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm

Not in any best-of list we track yet.

Garmin Vivoactive 5

Garmin Vivoactive 5

On more lists11listsThe number of best-of lists from test sites, magazines and YouTube reviewers that include the Garmin Vivoactive 5.
–#1 or awardLists that rank the Garmin Vivoactive 5 first, or name it the best in a category (for example best value or best overall).
2top 3 in 2 of 11Lists that rank the Garmin Vivoactive 5 first, second or third, plus the awards.
Named best forSports smartwatchCheap Garmin watchBeginnersValue for moneyOnboard music storage

What reviewers say about the Apple Watch Series 4 40mm and Garmin Vivoactive 5

Topics that expert and video reviewers praise or criticise. Open a topic to read what they wrote.

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm · 22 reviews

Reviewers praise the great display, easy controls and fitness tracking, but battery life is short and some features aren't available everywhere.

Garmin Vivoactive 5
Garmin Vivoactive 5 · 21 reviews

Reviewers praise the long battery life and solid health tracking, but miss an altimeter and are split on smart features.

3 praise · 11 criticise
Battery lifereviewers
13 praise · 3 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Battery lasts days in power saving modeMarty (video)
Battery lasts more than a day with light useFRED (video)
Battery lasts about a day and a half with short daily chargesiSenaCode (video)
Fall detection drains the battery quickly, so the watch may need charging before the 18 hours is upchoose.co.uk
Needs charging once a day, so fall detection could fail if the watch runs flat; Battery lasts under two days, which limits sleep trackingtechradar.com
GPS recording lasts about 6 hours before power-saving mode kicks incyclist.co.uk
Won't last several days, so it needs a nightly chargetrustedreviews.com
Battery hasn't improved, about a day and a half per charge, which limits trips away from home; Still needs its own charger, so it can't charge on a wireless phone padirishtimes.com
Battery drops quickly with heavy GPS or heart-rate trackingtechgearlab.com
Battery drops to about 5 to 6 hours in cellular modeHDblog (video)
Battery life has room to improve, though it beats expectationsFRED (video)
Cellular mode shortens battery life more than Apple claimsiPhoneItalia (video)
Battery needs charging every night and lasts under two days; No wireless charging, and the speech feature often switches itself offTechnikFreundYT (video)
No sleep tracking, and battery lasts about a day and a halfMobileWorld (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Up to 11 days of battery on one chargegaragegymreviews.com
11-day battery held up in mixed use with several GPS runsrunmorph.com
Up to 11 days in normal use, or 21 days in power-saving modelaardilladigital.com
Up to 11 days in watch mode, so you rarely think about chargingfitnesshero.fr
Charged about every three days, even with the always-on displayablogtowatch.com
Battery lasts a week or more and charges quicklyTestventure (video)
Battery lasts around ten days with always-on display offOutOfBit (video)
Battery life is excellent, up to around eleven days in smartwatch modeTodo Review Tech (video)
Battery lasts over 11 days in normal daily useCHIP (video)
Excellent battery life for a smartwatchDiscoverdose (video)
Battery lasts around 12 to 13 days in standard modeAndrea Volpi (video)
Battery life is goodDC Rainmaker (video)
Improved battery life and broad everyday health trackingSport Technik (video)
Always-on screen cuts battery life from 11 days to 5; GPS with music drains the battery in about 8 hours; Charges only with Garmin's own cable, not a universal USB onelaardilladigital.com
The pulse oximeter is a major power drain, halving battery life when onCHIP (video)
Music playback cuts battery life to about eight hours; The always-on display cuts battery life to five or six daysAndrea Volpi (video)
15 praise · 2 criticise
Displayreviewers
8 praise · 2 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Screen more than 30% larger, with bigger icons that are easier to readtomsguide.com
Larger display with rounded edges, giving more room for information; Digital Crown gives haptic clicks as you scroll through liststechradar.com
Screen runs edge to edge, reaching 1,000 nits for reading in sunlighttrustedreviews.com
Bigger screen fits more on watch faces, so you tap lessirishtimes.com
44mm screen is more than 30% larger than the old model, easier to read and tap; Crown clicks with haptic feedback, so scrolling feels precisetechadvisor.com
Touchscreen responds with almost no delay, plus the crown and two buttonstechgearlab.com
Digital crown gives a small vibration at each step, like a mechanical clickmac4ever.com
Haptic feedback on the digital crownMarty (video)
Larger display with thinner bezelsHDblog (video)
Bigger edge-to-edge display that is easier to readiPhoned (video)
Bigger display that nearly matches the previous large sizeTechnikFreundYT (video)
Larger screen with slimmer bezels and rounded cornersiPhoneItalia (video)
Larger display makes quick actions easy to readTechnikFreundYT (video)
Larger, bright OLED display with rounded edgesMobileWorld (video)
Bigger screen makes messages and maps easier to readiSenaCode (video)
No always-on display, so you have to raise your wrist to see the timetrustedreviews.com
No always-on screen or automatic brightness, so you have to wake it to see the time; Touchscreen may be unreliable while submergedtechgearlab.com
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Round watch with a bright 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreenhrdlpn.nl
AMOLED screen, bright and readable even in strong sunlightlaardilladigital.com
Bright, colorful AMOLED screen on par with the Galaxy Watch 4 Classicdigitaltrends.com
Vivid AMOLED touchscreen displayThe Run Testers (video)
Clear AMOLED display with adjustable watch facesRosie Andre (video)
Sharp, bright AMOLED display with adjustable font sizeCHIP (video)
The display is excellentDC Rainmaker (video)
AMOLED display is a standout for this price classSport Technik (video)
Screen is less bright in full sunfitnesshero.fr
Running screens use plain white text rather than the AMOLED's colorsdigitaltrends.com
6 praise · 5 criticise
Design and buildreviewers
4 praise · 6 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Gold stainless steel is the first gold Apple Watch anyone can buy; Gold model suits casual wear through to a blazer and dress pants, with a gold Milanese loop; Recessed dock button and new ceramic underside look more like a watch than a gadgetthesweetsetup.com
Gold finish looks better than the iPhone version; Ceramic back is striking and attractiveTechnikFreundYT (video)
Premium finish with a watchmaking-inspired designFRED (video)
Excellent build quality with 50-metre water resistanceMobileWorld (video)
Attractive design and a fast, smooth 64-bit processoriSenaCode (video)
Looks good and is comfortable to wearCinn’s World (video)
White sport band looks geeky next to the gold finishthesweetsetup.com
Aluminium screen picked up light scratches within daystechadvisor.com
Stainless steel case scratched after 15 days with no rubbing on abrasivesmac4ever.com
Crown scratched within the first days of useTechnikFreundYT (video)
Screen uses Ion-X glass rather than a tougher coveriSenaCode (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Refined look, more polished than some advanced Garmin sports watchesgaragegymreviews.com
Well-built design with a good price-performance ratioTestventure (video)
Attractive design with a comfortable fitPreTriathlon (video)
High-quality build that stays light and comfortable to wearSport Technik (video)
Screen may scratch easilygaragegymreviews.com
Looks less feminine than the Garmin Lily 2hrdlpn.nl
Metal charging contacts can corrode if left wetdigitaltrends.com
Aluminium bezel instead of stainless steelThe Run Testers (video)
Less rugged build than the Fenix or Epix seriesTodo Review Tech (video)
Almost entirely plastic, so it does not feel premiumDiscoverdose (video)
6 praise · 2 criticise
Size and weightreviewers
7 praise · 2 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Thinner than Series 3 despite the larger screen, so it feels light on the wristchoose.co.uk
Sleek enough to wear every day, and it fits under cuffscyclist.co.uk
Rounded corners and a flatter body sit more comfortably on the wristthesweetsetup.com
Thinner design with softer edges and curved screenMark's Tech Vlogs (video)
Comfortable strap for everyday wearMarty (video)
Case size feels just right on a smaller wristTechnikFreundYT (video)
The 40mm case, 2mm bigger than the old 38mm, felt too big at firsttomsguide.com
Heavier than before: 44mm aluminium 36.7g, stainless 47.9gtechadvisor.com
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Light at 36g with strap, barely noticed even when worn to sleephorloge-du-coureur.fr
Weighs 36g with strap, barely felt on the wrist even overnightrunmorph.com
At 36g and 42mm, comfortable enough to wear 24/7, even to beddigitaltrends.com
Compact, light case that is comfortable day and nightOutOfBit (video)
Light and comfortable for all-day wearTodo Review Tech (video)
Very light and comfortable on the wristAndrea Volpi (video)
Ideal size for a training-focused smartwatchPreTriathlon (video)
42mm case may look small on larger wristsgymstreet.fr
Smaller case than most rival smartwatchesAndrea Volpi (video)
3 criticise
Sleep trackingreviewers
6 praise · 5 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
No sleep trackingchoose.co.uk
No built-in sleep tracking, so you need a third-party appMark's Tech Vlogs (video)
No sleep tracking, since the watch does not focus on sleepTechnikFreundYT (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Recovery time and training effect shown after each workoutgaragegymreviews.com
Body Battery from HRV and sleep, which matched the reviewer's own energy levels; Sleep report with detailed phases and a score, showing how alcohol lowers itfitnesshero.fr
Sleep phases and a score, with the screen switching off at night; Body Battery rates energy from 1 to 100 using sleep, activity and stressgymstreet.fr
Built-in sleep coach, stress tracking and recovery timeablogtowatch.com
Body Battery and wheelchair mode are useful and rareLes Alexiens - Domotique & Maison Connectée (video)
Newer features such as nap detection and sleep tracking work wellDC Rainmaker (video)
No daily training readiness score, which more advanced Garmin watches includegaragegymreviews.com
Sleep Coach adds little to sleep trackingLes Alexiens - Domotique & Maison Connectée (video)
Lacks some specialised training features, such as training readinessTodo Review Tech (video)
Sleep tracking triggers too easily when you are just lying downDiscoverdose (video)
Sleep Coach recommendations are questionableDC Rainmaker (video)
not mentioned
Health trackingreviewers
11 praise · 3 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Nap tracking, female health tracking and guided meditationgaragegymreviews.com
Wrist heart rate, SpO2 and VO2 max built inhrdlpn.nl
Health suite with Body Battery, overnight HRV, sleep and stress trackingrunmorph.com
Pulse oximeter for oxygen levels, useful while acclimatizing to altitudelaardilladigital.com
Counts 15–20% more steps than a phone, for more accurate daily activityfitnesshero.fr
After one calibration run, distance was within 0.02 miles of the treadmillablogtowatch.com
Stress tracking spotted an oncoming fever before any symptoms appeareddigitaltrends.com
Very detailed step, sleep, heart rate and fitness data; Reliable daily health monitoring, including stress and sleep analysisTestventure (video)
Precise activity and health tracking with a very detailed appLes Alexiens - Domotique & Maison Connectée (video)
Useful health data including heart rate, body battery and sleep score; Women's health tracking is handy to check regularlyRosie Andre (video)
Complete health and sports featuresPreTriathlon (video)
Activity tracking missed one morning and needed troubleshootingRosie Andre (video)
The calorie counter needs extra appsCHIP (video)
No ECG feature because of the polymer bezelPreTriathlon (video)
10 praise · 2 criticise
Fitness trackingreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Automatic workout detection asks to log a session you started without pressing anythingchoose.co.uk
GPS tracks rides without a phone, logging kilometre splits and heart rate; Detects runs and walks, offering to record them from when movement begancyclist.co.uk
Weekly activity challenges against friends who share their datatechadvisor.com
Step count was off by only 11 to 34 steps on a mile-long walktechgearlab.com
Strong fitness tracking, especially swimming and runningMark's Tech Vlogs (video)
Broad health and fitness feature setFRED (video)
Activity rings motivate daily movementTechnikFreundYT (video)
Motivating activity trackingAlex Reframe (video)
Strong fitness and motivation featuresMobileWorld (video)
Activity and heart rate tracking that motivatesCinn’s World (video)
Won't pair with power meters, so no cycling power datacyclist.co.uk
Stair count missed flights in testingtechgearlab.com
Garmin Vivoactive 5Not mentioned by reviewers.
not mentioned
Smart featuresreviewers
5 praise · 7 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Plays music offline from Spotify, Deezer or Amazon Music, so you can leave the phone at home on runshorloge-du-coureur.fr
Music and Garmin Pay, so the phone can stay at home on a runhrdlpn.nl
Garmin Pay, so you can leave the wallet at home on a rungymstreet.fr
The alarm vibration is discreet and works wellRosie Andre (video)
Music storage, Garmin Pay and a detailed weather appDiscoverdose (video)
No microphone, so no calls from the wristgaragegymreviews.com
Can't make calls or reply to texts on the watchablogtowatch.com
Inactivity alerts chime several times a day, even while doing choresdigitaltrends.com
Cannot reply to messages or images on iOSTestventure (video)
No microphone, speaker or voice assistant, so calls cannot be takenLes Alexiens - Domotique & Maison Connectée (video)
No call answering, microphone or voice assistant; iPhone users cannot reply to notificationsOutOfBit (video)
Do-not-disturb and call or text settings are still confusing to set upRosie Andre (video)
7 praise · 3 criticise
Watch faces and interfacereviewers
not mentioned
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Set up in under five minutes over Bluetooth, without reading instructionschoose.co.uk
Infograph face shows up to eight complications at oncetrustedreviews.com
Infograph face shows the day's highs and lows, not just the current temperaturetechadvisor.com
Bigger screen with larger buttons, so PIN entry and menus are easier; Modular Infograph centre shows weather or activity history through the daymac4ever.com
New watch faces that use the full display welliPhoneItalia (video)
Design and customisation options, including watch facesTechnikFreundYT (video)
Many watch faces, changeable through the appCinn’s World (video)
Existing watch faces were simply scaled up rather than redesigned for the bigger screenmac4ever.com
Interface and watch faces feel dense and somewhat busyMobileWorld (video)
Menus and settings take time to get used toCinn’s World (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5Not mentioned by reviewers.
7 praise · 2 criticise
Speaker and voicereviewers
not mentioned
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Raise to Speak lets you talk to Siri just by lifting your wristtomsguide.com
Calls are clear with no echo, and Apple says the speaker is 50% louderchoose.co.uk
Louder speaker than beforetechradar.com
Louder speaker and relocated microphone make calls cleareririshtimes.com
Louder speaker and improved digital crownMark's Tech Vlogs (video)
Louder, better-placed microphone for phone callsiPhoned (video)
Useful Siri timers and remindersAlex Reframe (video)
Walkie Talkie needed a four-minute wait to connect, then dropped after a few minuteschoose.co.uk
Speaker is loud but mainly used for Siri answers, not podcasts or musictrustedreviews.com
Garmin Vivoactive 5Not mentioned by reviewers.
4 praise · 4 criticise
Apps and notificationsreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Apple Pay works at any contactless terminal, paying straight from the watchtechgearlab.com
Quick notifications and information at a glance on the wristAlex Reframe (video)
Fast, useful notifications and Apple Pay supportMobileWorld (video)
Quick actions and notifications are easy to read at a glanceiSenaCode (video)
Rides recorded in Apple's Workout app don't reach Strava without a third-party appcyclist.co.uk
You can't record video or post Instagram Stories on the watchiPhoneItalia (video)
Limited use beyond notifications, timers and basic informationAlex Reframe (video)
Few third-party apps yet, though the selection is improvingiSenaCode (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5Not mentioned by reviewers.
not mentioned
Heart rate accuracyreviewers
6 praise · 2 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Heart rate within 1–2 bpm of a chest strap, even on fast interval sessionshorloge-du-coureur.fr
Heart rate within 1–2 bpm of a chest strap, even on interval sessionsrunmorph.com
Heart rate tracking as precise as pricier Garmin modelsDiscoverdose (video)
Heart rate and oxygen readings are accurate compared with other watchesAndrea Volpi (video)
Heart rate and GPS track workouts accuratelyPreTriathlon (video)
Heart rate stays close to a chest strap during intervals and long ridesDC Rainmaker (video)
Heart rate sensor less advanced than premium Fenix modelsTodo Review Tech (video)
Optical heart rate readings unreliable during strength trainingSport Technik (video)
7 praise
Performancereviewers
not mentioned
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Bright screen and a processor twice as fast as Series 3, with no lagcyclist.co.uk
Startup takes 43 seconds, down from 1 minute 30 seconds on Series 3, and apps open almost instantlymac4ever.com
Noticeably faster S4 processor than previous generationsMark's Tech Vlogs (video)
Smooth, fast performance on watchOS 5Marty (video)
Faster processor and smoother interfaceHDblog (video)
Very responsive processor and excellent screenFRED (video)
Better performance and a welcome design changeiPhoneItalia (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5Not mentioned by reviewers.
3 praise · 4 criticise
Bands and strapsreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Older Apple and third-party straps still fit the new sizes; Sport Loop's Velcro closure fits almost any wristtrustedreviews.com
Existing Apple bands still fitHDblog (video)
Older watch bands still fit the new modeliPhoned (video)
Older bands like the Classic Buckle don't line up perfectly at the lugs; Gold model needs a separate sport band for workoutsthesweetsetup.com
Velcro Nike+ strap looks too sporty for dressy occasionsMarty (video)
No classic brown leather strap with a proper buckleTechnikFreundYT (video)
Fitting the band and clasp takes some effortCinn’s World (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5Not mentioned by reviewers.
6 criticise
Feature availability by regionreviewers
not mentioned
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
ECG was only enabled in select countries at firsttechradar.com
ECG arrives later, US first, with no date set for Irelandirishtimes.com
ECG not available in the UK at review time, so the heart feature is untestedtechadvisor.com
Electrocardiogram feature not yet available at launchMarty (video)
ECG feature not yet available in the Netherlands; Some health features still await European approvaliPhoned (video)
Some health features arrive later in Europe than in the USFRED (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5Not mentioned by reviewers.
2 praise · 4 criticise
Cellular and iPhonereviewers
not mentioned
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Standalone LTE for calls and notificationsHDblog (video)
Cellular connection lets you leave the phone at homeiPhoneItalia (video)
Still needs a compatible iPhone, even the LTE modeltechadvisor.com
The cellular model only makes sense if you often leave your phone at homeMark's Tech Vlogs (video)
Cellular reception is good but not excellentiPhoneItalia (video)
Works only with an iPhone, and cellular support in Italy is limitedMobileWorld (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5Not mentioned by reviewers.
not mentioned
Altimeterreviewers
6 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
Garmin Vivoactive 5
No barometric altimeter, which limits advanced outdoor usehorloge-du-coureur.fr
No barometric altimeter, so mountain elevation gain is inaccuraterunmorph.com
No barometric altimeter, so altitude comes only from GPSablogtowatch.com
No altimeter, so climbed floors are not countedCHIP (video)
No barometric altimeter, so elevation gain is not shownPreTriathlon (video)
No barometric altimeter and no multi-band GPSDC Rainmaker (video)
not mentioned
Strapsreviewers
5 praise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Quick-release 20mm strap for swapping between sport and everyday lookshorloge-du-coureur.fr
Comfortable strap you forget about during exercisehrdlpn.nl
Soft silicone strap that is barely felt on the wrist day and nightgymstreet.fr
Uses standard 20mm Quick Release 2.0 straps, which are easy to swapdigitaltrends.com
Removable straps and a familiar charging cableThe Run Testers (video)
not mentioned
Swimmingreviewers
1 praise · 3 criticise
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mmNot mentioned by reviewers.
Garmin Vivoactive 5
5 ATM water resistance, suited to pool and open-water swimminglaardilladigital.com
Swim tracking missed the first length unless restartedRosie Andre (video)
Swim lap detection counts simple stroke changes as lapsDiscoverdose (video)
Cannot follow swim workouts and lacks swim technique detectionPreTriathlon (video)
3 criticise
Price and valuereviewers
not mentioned
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Overtaken by the Series 5 and Series 7 with newer featurestomsguide.com
Pricier than earlier models; Less of a reason to upgrade for Series 3 ownersHDblog (video)
Not essential; you can easily manage without itAlex Reframe (video)
Garmin Vivoactive 5Not mentioned by reviewers.

Green = reviewers praise it, red = they criticise it. Counts are reviews that mention the topic.

What owners say about the Apple Watch Series 4 40mm and Garmin Vivoactive 5

From owners' comments under review videos. Open a topic to read what owners report.

60%positive

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm

219 owners60% positive13% mixed27% negative

Owners praise its speed, useful health and phone features, while short battery life remains the clearest frustration.

40%positive

Garmin Vivoactive 5

154 owners40% positive22% mixed38% negative

Owners value its long battery, fitness features, and comfort, but cite tracking errors, battery drain, and message limits.

18 like it · 37 dislike it
Batteryowners mention
10 like it · 10 dislike it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Long-lasting battery between chargesOwners say the battery easily lasts a day or more, with some getting two or three days on light use, especially when the watch is paired with an iPhone.18 owners
Short battery life and rapid drainOwners say battery life drops fast, often to 20% or less within a day, when they use calls, music, GPS or apps, and the always-on display is not offered.37 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Long battery lifeOwners report the battery lasts about a week on a charge with Bluetooth on, far longer than Samsung or Fitbit watches.10 owners
Battery drains faster than expectedOwners say the battery drains quickly when activity detection, always-on pulse oximeter, all-day Bluetooth, or many notifications are enabled; turning those features off helps.10 owners
17 like it · 21 dislike it
Messages, apps and phoneowners mention
15 dislike it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Cellular freedom for quick tripsOwners say the cellular model lets them leave their phone at home for walks, errands and runs, and still make calls and texts from the watch.10 owners
Handy on-wrist calls, texts and alertsOwners say on-wrist call, text and alert notifications are convenient, especially when they cannot hear their phone.7 owners
Accidental emergency and fall alertsOwners say fall detection and emergency alerts go off by accident, such as when bending over or washing hands, and that Raise to Siri works only sometimes.5 owners
Missing or limited social and messaging appsOwners say popular social and messaging apps like Instagram and WhatsApp are missing or limited on the watch, with some apps removed over time.5 owners
Slow or failed cellular activationOwners say cellular activation can fail or take days, with error messages or store visits needed to get the LTE service working.4 owners
Too dependent on iPhone or internetOwners say the watch depends on the iPhone, so music, Strava data and some features stop working when the phone is out of range.4 owners
Unreliable Siri commandsOwners say Siri often fails to understand or respond to commands, which makes voice control unreliable.3 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Message replies and photos often failOwners say WhatsApp photos do not show on the watch and replies often fail to appear, especially with iPhone pairing.10 owners
Bluetooth pairing and phone connections dropOwners say the watch drops its Bluetooth connection to the phone often, sometimes within minutes, and this can stop headphones or hearing aids from pairing.5 owners
11 like it · 6 dislike it
Screenowners mention
7 like it · 12 dislike it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Larger, brighter, roomier screenOwners say the bigger, brighter screen is roomy and easy to read, and that it feels like a clear upgrade from older Apple Watch models.11 owners
Screen scratches too easilyOwners say the screen scratches easily, with one owner reporting visible marks after only four days of normal wear.3 owners
Screen artifacts and uneven brightnessOwners say the screen shows a visible grid pattern and uneven brightness near the edges, and some find the bright colours distracting.3 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Bright, clear screen outdoorsOwners say the display is good and readable outdoors in sunlight, and one notes the AMOLED screen looks much better than earlier Garmin models.7 owners
Small watch face with oversized bezelsOwners say the 42 mm case has oversized bezels and a small display, and some felt it looked too small on the wrist.6 owners
Screen is hard to wake or read6 owners
12 like it
GPS, maps and altitudeowners mention
13 dislike it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Fast, responsive performanceOwners say the Series 4 is much quicker than earlier models, with apps and navigation loading and responding noticeably faster.12 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Menus and setup feel confusingOwners find the menus and button layout confusing, and some workouts and routes created in Garmin Connect cannot be sent to the watch.7 owners
No altimeter or reliable ski trackingOwners say the watch has no barometric altimeter, so it cannot record lift rides when skiing and the altitude field is not useful.6 owners
8 like it
Heart rate and healthowners mention
17 like it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Useful ECG and heart health featuresOwners say the ECG and heart rate features are useful, and that fall detection gives them peace of mind.8 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Lots of useful fitness and health features17 owners
11 like it
Sports and fitnessowners mention
12 dislike it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Fitness tracking and activity ringsOwners say the fitness tracking works well, with automatic workout logging in the Health app and daily activity rings that keep them motivated.11 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Step counts miss or invent movementOwners say the step counter adds steps during arm movement, driving, or chess, and misses steps while pushing a stroller.7 owners
Swimming tracking and workout options are limitedOwners say swimming tracking is limited: pool workouts with rest intervals show little detail, and custom swim workouts from Garmin Connect cannot be sent to the watch.5 owners
5 like it
Sleep trackingowners mention
9 like it · 7 dislike it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Automatic sleep tracking through appsOwners say third-party sleep tracking apps run automatically in the background and sync to Apple Health, so no manual start is needed.5 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Easy to use and responsiveOwners find the watch responsive and intuitive to handle, with the sleep and distance tracking also judged accurate in their experience.6 owners
Accurate sleep trackingOwners say the sleep tracking is accurate, with some comparing it favorably to Apple and Samsung watches.3 owners
Sleep tracking misses or misjudges restOwners say sleep tracking is unreliable, often missing the first hour of sleep, counting light sleep or wakefulness as sleep, and missing naps.7 owners
5 dislike it
Price and valueowners mention
11 like it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
High price for a smartwatchOwners say the Series 4 is expensive for a smartwatch, and some feel the features do not justify the price.5 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Good value for the priceSeveral owners say it is priced well for what it does, with the price cited as the main reason they chose it over the Venu 3.11 owners
8 like it
Comfort and sizeowners mention
7 like it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Comfortable, slim fit on the wristOwners say the 40mm case is slim and light, which makes it comfortable to wear all day, especially compared with the 44mm model.8 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Lightweight and comfortable on the wristOwners say it is very light, around 36 g with the band, and comfortable enough to wear all day and night.7 owners
9 like it
Build and designowners mention
4 like it
▶
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm
Attractive finishes and stylish designOwners say the aluminum and stainless steel finishes look attractive, and the 40mm size suits smaller wrists.9 owners
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Slim, understated watch designOwners say the watch is slim, around 11 mm thick, and thin enough to wear under clothing such as a dress shirt or tailcoat.4 owners

All specs: Apple Watch Series 4 40mm vs Garmin Vivoactive 5

Apple Watch Series 4 40mmApple Watch Series 4 40mm

Winner

Garmin Vivoactive 5Garmin Vivoactive 5

Price

Overall score
7.9
8.1
Technical score
7.1
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has the highest technical score.
7.1
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the highest technical score.
Popularity
5.2
10
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the highest popularity.
Reviews score
8.6
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm: Reviews score
8.5
Value for money
8.4
8.5
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the highest value-for-money score.
Running
7.8
8.6
Swimming
9.7
9.7
Health monitoring
5.1
6.0
Sleep tracking
6.4
7.7
Hiking
8.3
1.9
Seniors
7.1
6.4
Health
5.9
7.6
Heart rate monitor
yes
What it is
A built-in sensor that measures your pulse directly from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a heart rate monitor. 9.5% of smartwatches include a heart rate monitor.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
A built-in sensor that measures your pulse directly from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a heart rate monitor. 9.5% of smartwatches include a heart rate monitor.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Blood oxygen monitoring
no
What it is
A wrist-based feature that estimates blood oxygen saturation over time.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support blood oxygen monitoring. 69.7% of smartwatches support blood oxygen monitoring.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
A wrist-based feature that estimates blood oxygen saturation over time.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports blood oxygen monitoring. 30.4% of smartwatches support blood oxygen monitoring.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Garmin Vivoactive 5 tracks blood oxygen levels.
ECG
yes
What it is
The ability to record a single-lead electrocardiogram from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports ECG. 82% of smartwatches support ECG.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports ECG.
no
What it is
The ability to record a single-lead electrocardiogram from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support ECG. 18.2% of smartwatches support ECG.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Irregular heart rate warnings
yes
What it is
Notifications that flag heart-rate patterns which appear unusually irregular.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports irregular heart rate warnings. 49.5% of smartwatches support irregular heart rate warnings.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Notifications that flag heart-rate patterns which appear unusually irregular.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports irregular heart rate warnings. 49.5% of smartwatches support irregular heart rate warnings.
Priority:
LOW
Supports abnormal high/low heart-rate alerts (typically after inactivity).
HRV tracking
yes
What it is
Measurement of heart-rate variability, the change in timing between heartbeats.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports HRV tracking. 54.9% of smartwatches support HRV tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
Measurement of heart-rate variability, the change in timing between heartbeats.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports HRV tracking. 54.9% of smartwatches support HRV tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
HRV may be estimated from sleep/stress methods and not medical-grade.
Blood pressure monitoring
no
What it is
Blood pressure measurement or estimation features available through the watch ecosystem.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support blood pressure monitoring. 21.9% of smartwatches support blood pressure monitoring.
Priority:
MEDIUM
no
What it is
Blood pressure measurement or estimation features available through the watch ecosystem.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support blood pressure monitoring. 21.9% of smartwatches support blood pressure monitoring.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Temperature sensor
no
What it is
A sensor that records skin or wrist temperature changes and longer-term trends.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not include a temperature sensor. 32% of smartwatches include a temperature sensor.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
A sensor that records skin or wrist temperature changes and longer-term trends.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a temperature sensor. 68.2% of smartwatches include a temperature sensor.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Temperature readings may be skin/ambient trends, not core-body medical values.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a temperature sensor.
Fingertip sensor
no
What it is
Whether the smartwatch includes a dedicated fingertip-contact health sensor.
When it matters
When you want faster spot checks or more precise fingertip-based health measurements on the watch itself.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not include a fingertip sensor. 0.8% of smartwatches include a fingertip sensor.
Good value:
🎯 yes
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
Whether the smartwatch includes a dedicated fingertip-contact health sensor.
When it matters
When you want faster spot checks or more precise fingertip-based health measurements on the watch itself.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include a fingertip sensor. 0.8% of smartwatches include a fingertip sensor.
Good value:
🎯 yes
Priority:
LOW
Stress monitoring
no
What it is
Stress estimates derived from heart rate, HRV, or similar body signals.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support stress monitoring. 68.8% of smartwatches support stress monitoring.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Stress estimates derived from heart rate, HRV, or similar body signals.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports stress monitoring. 31.3% of smartwatches support stress monitoring.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 tracks stress.
Sleep tracking
yes
What it is
Automatic recording of sleep duration, stages, or sleep quality from overnight wear.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports sleep tracking. 6.2% of smartwatches support sleep tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
Automatic recording of sleep duration, stages, or sleep quality from overnight wear.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports sleep tracking. 6.2% of smartwatches support sleep tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Perspiration monitoring
no
What it is
Support for sweat-related sensing or estimates tied to perspiration during wear or training.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not track perspiration. 15.2% of smartwatches track perspiration.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Support for sweat-related sensing or estimates tied to perspiration during wear or training.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 tracks perspiration. 85% of smartwatches track perspiration.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 tracks perspiration.
Calorie intake tracking
no
What it is
Estimated calorie burn based on movement, heart data, and user profile inputs.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support calorie tracking. 48.8% of smartwatches support calorie tracking.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Estimated calorie burn based on movement, heart data, and user profile inputs.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports calorie tracking. 51.4% of smartwatches support calorie tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Food logging may require a companion or third-party app.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 tracks calories burned.
VO2 max measurement
yes
What it is
Estimated VO2 max, a fitness metric linked to aerobic capacity and endurance.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm measures VO2 max. 48.8% of smartwatches measure VO2 max.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
Estimated VO2 max, a fitness metric linked to aerobic capacity and endurance.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 measures VO2 max. 48.8% of smartwatches measure VO2 max.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Readiness score
no
What it is
A recovery-style score that combines recent activity, sleep, and body data into one summary.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support readiness scores. 19.8% of smartwatches support readiness scores.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A recovery-style score that combines recent activity, sleep, and body data into one summary.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support readiness scores. 19.8% of smartwatches support readiness scores.
Priority:
LOW
Weight tracking
yes
What it is
Logging or syncing of body-weight records over time.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports weight tracking. 58.1% of smartwatches support weight tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Tracked through the companion app or smart-scale sync.
yes
What it is
Logging or syncing of body-weight records over time.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports weight tracking. 58.1% of smartwatches support weight tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Weight tracking may rely on manual app entry or smart-scale sync.
Water intake tracking
no
What it is
Logging tools for recording daily water consumption.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not track water intake. 44.2% of smartwatches track water intake.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Logging tools for recording daily water consumption.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 tracks water intake. 55.9% of smartwatches track water intake.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 tracks water intake.
Menstrual cycle tracking
yes
What it is
Cycle logging and related predictions available through the watch and its health tools.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports menstrual cycle tracking. 33.2% of smartwatches support menstrual cycle tracking.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Cycle logging and related predictions available through the watch and its health tools.
When it matters
When you want health data from your wrist during the day or night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports menstrual cycle tracking. 33.2% of smartwatches support menstrual cycle tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Inactivity alerts
yes
What it is
Reminders that prompt you to move after long periods of inactivity.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports inactivity alerts. 7.4% of smartwatches support inactivity alerts.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Reminders that prompt you to move after long periods of inactivity.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports inactivity alerts. 7.4% of smartwatches support inactivity alerts.
Priority:
LOW
Smart scale compatibility
yes
What it is
Compatibility with smart scales for syncing weight and body-composition data.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports smart scale compatibility. 43% of smartwatches support smart scale compatibility.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Compatibility with smart scales for syncing weight and body-composition data.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports smart scale compatibility. 43% of smartwatches support smart scale compatibility.
Priority:
LOW
Release date
2018
What it is
The year the watch model was first released, which hints at how modern its chipset, sensors and operating system are.
When it matters
Matters most when buying a discounted or second-hand model, since older releases tend to lose software and app updates sooner.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm was released in 2018, which is less recent than 80.6% of Smartwatches and the same as 4.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 2023 or newer
Priority:
LOW
September 2018
2023
What it is
The year the watch model was first released, which hints at how modern its chipset, sensors and operating system are.
When it matters
Matters most when buying a discounted or second-hand model, since older releases tend to lose software and app updates sooner.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 was released in 2023, which is more recent than 65.6% of Smartwatches and the same as 17.6% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 2023 or newer
Priority:
LOW
September 2023
Garmin Vivoactive 5 is the most recently released model.
Brand name
Apple
Garmin
Fitness
9.9
7.7
Accelerometer
yes
What it is
A motion sensor that measures acceleration, steps, gestures, and general movement.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes an accelerometer. 0.5% of smartwatches include an accelerometer.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A motion sensor that measures acceleration, steps, gestures, and general movement.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes an accelerometer. 0.5% of smartwatches include an accelerometer.
Priority:
LOW
Barometer
yes
What it is
A pressure sensor used for altitude changes, elevation estimates, and weather-related context.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a barometer. 46.5% of smartwatches include a barometer.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a barometer.
no
What it is
A pressure sensor used for altitude changes, elevation estimates, and weather-related context.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include a barometer. 53.6% of smartwatches include a barometer.
Priority:
LOW
Gyroscope
yes
What it is
A motion sensor that measures rotation and helps interpret wrist movement more accurately.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a gyroscope. 28.9% of smartwatches include a gyroscope.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a gyroscope.
no
What it is
A motion sensor that measures rotation and helps interpret wrist movement more accurately.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include a gyroscope. 71.3% of smartwatches include a gyroscope.
Priority:
LOW
Cadence sensor
yes
What it is
A sensor input used to measure step or pedal rhythm during training.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a cadence sensor. 67.2% of smartwatches include a cadence sensor.
Priority:
LOW
Cadence may require external sensor/app pairing on some models.
yes
What it is
A sensor input used to measure step or pedal rhythm during training.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a cadence sensor. 67.2% of smartwatches include a cadence sensor.
Priority:
LOW
Cadence may require external sensor/app pairing on some models.
Distance tracking
yes
What it is
The ability to measure how far you move during walks, runs, rides, or other activities.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports distance tracking. 3.7% of smartwatches support distance tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
The ability to measure how far you move during walks, runs, rides, or other activities.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports distance tracking. 3.7% of smartwatches support distance tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Step tracking
yes
What it is
Automatic counting of daily steps and similar walking movement.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports step tracking. 0.8% of smartwatches support step tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
Automatic counting of daily steps and similar walking movement.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports step tracking. 0.8% of smartwatches support step tracking.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Pace tracking
yes
What it is
Tracking of current or average pace during activities such as running or cycling.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports pace tracking. 19.5% of smartwatches support pace tracking.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Tracking of current or average pace during activities such as running or cycling.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports pace tracking. 19.5% of smartwatches support pace tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Elevation tracking
yes
What it is
Tracking of climbed, descended, or current elevation during activities.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports elevation tracking. 32.4% of smartwatches support elevation tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm tracks elevation.
no
What it is
Tracking of climbed, descended, or current elevation during activities.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support elevation tracking. 67.7% of smartwatches support elevation tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Route tracker
yes
What it is
Route recording that stores the path taken during an outdoor session.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports route tracking. 23% of smartwatches support route tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm tracks routes.
no
What it is
Route recording that stores the path taken during an outdoor session.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support route tracking. 77.1% of smartwatches support route tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Live tracking
?
yes
What it is
Real-time sharing of your route or location with other people during an activity.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports live tracking. 10.5% of smartwatches support live tracking.
Priority:
LOW
Maximum altitude
3,000 m
What it is
The highest elevation above sea level, in metres, at which the watch is rated to operate and record accurate readings.
When it matters
Matters for hikers, climbers and skiers who go above a few thousand metres, where a low rating could leave the altimeter unreliable.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is rated to 3,000 m, which is lower than 59.1% of Smartwatches and the same as 40.9% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=8900 m
Priority:
LOW
?
Multi-sport mode
yes
What it is
A training mode designed to handle multiple sports within a single session.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a multi-sport mode. 28.4% of smartwatches include a multi-sport mode.
Priority:
LOW
Available in the Workout app on watchOS 9 or later.
yes
What it is
A training mode designed to handle multiple sports within a single session.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a multi-sport mode. 28.4% of smartwatches include a multi-sport mode.
Priority:
LOW
Swim sport mode
yes
What it is
A dedicated workout mode tuned for pool or open-water swimming.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a swim sport mode. 23.1% of smartwatches include a swim sport mode.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A dedicated workout mode tuned for pool or open-water swimming.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a swim sport mode. 23.1% of smartwatches include a swim sport mode.
Priority:
LOW
Exercise tagging
yes
What it is
The ability to label or classify workouts by exercise type.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports exercise tagging. 5.8% of smartwatches support exercise tagging.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
The ability to label or classify workouts by exercise type.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports exercise tagging. 5.8% of smartwatches support exercise tagging.
Priority:
LOW
Number of exercises
80
What it is
How many preset workout types are built in, such as running, cycling, yoga or rowing, each with tailored metrics.
When it matters
Useful if you switch between several sports, like gym sessions, swimming and cycling, and want each tracked without creating custom workouts.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes 80 exercise types, which is fewer than 51.3% of Smartwatches and the same as 3.7% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=100
Priority:
LOW
Reported as at least 80 exercise modes.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes the most exercise types.
30
What it is
How many preset workout types are built in, such as running, cycling, yoga or rowing, each with tailored metrics.
When it matters
Useful if you switch between several sports, like gym sessions, swimming and cycling, and want each tracked without creating custom workouts.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes 30 exercise types, which is fewer than 63.6% of Smartwatches and the same as 1.8% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=100
Priority:
LOW
Reported as at least 30 exercise modes.
Automatic activity detection
yes
What it is
The ability to recognize certain workouts automatically without manual start.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports automatic activity detection. 18.3% of smartwatches support automatic activity detection.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
The ability to recognize certain workouts automatically without manual start.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports automatic activity detection. 18.3% of smartwatches support automatic activity detection.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Auto pause
yes
What it is
Automatic pausing of workout recording when movement stops.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports auto pause. 37.5% of smartwatches support auto pause.
Priority:
LOW
Auto-pause is typically available only in selected workout modes (for example running or cycling).
yes
What it is
Automatic pausing of workout recording when movement stops.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports auto pause. 37.5% of smartwatches support auto pause.
Priority:
LOW
Goal setting
yes
What it is
Tools for setting activity, health, or routine targets through the watch ecosystem.
When it matters
When you want extra help staying active or hitting your goals.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports goal setting. 1.9% of smartwatches support goal setting.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Tools for setting activity, health, or routine targets through the watch ecosystem.
When it matters
When you want extra help staying active or hitting your goals.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports goal setting. 1.9% of smartwatches support goal setting.
Priority:
LOW
Coaching
yes
What it is
Guided training or wellness suggestions based on your data and habits.
When it matters
When you track workouts and want better training data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports coaching. 41.3% of smartwatches support coaching.
Priority:
LOW
Coaching features available via companion app.
?
Achievements
yes
What it is
Badges or progress milestones awarded for activity and usage goals.
When it matters
When you want extra help staying active or hitting your goals.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports achievements. 13% of smartwatches support achievements.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Badges or progress milestones awarded for activity and usage goals.
When it matters
When you want extra help staying active or hitting your goals.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports achievements. 13% of smartwatches support achievements.
Priority:
LOW
Route support
yes
What it is
Support for following saved routes, courses, or turn guidance during activities.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports route support. 45.6% of smartwatches support route support.
Priority:
LOW
Route support available via companion app.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports routes.
no
What it is
Support for following saved routes, courses, or turn guidance during activities.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support route support. 54.5% of smartwatches support route support.
Priority:
LOW
Voice feedback
yes
What it is
Spoken prompts that report pace, laps, instructions, or other activity updates.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports voice feedback. 36.6% of smartwatches support voice feedback.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Spoken prompts that report pace, laps, instructions, or other activity updates.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports voice feedback. 36.6% of smartwatches support voice feedback.
Priority:
LOW
Spoken prompts work through a paired phone or Bluetooth headphones.
Heart rate strap support
yes
What it is
Compatibility with external chest straps or other heart-rate transmitters.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports external heart rate monitor compatibility. 53.5% of smartwatches support external heart rate monitor compatibility.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Compatibility with external chest straps or other heart-rate transmitters.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports external heart rate monitor compatibility. 53.5% of smartwatches support external heart rate monitor compatibility.
Priority:
LOW
Battery
3.4
5.6
Battery life
0.75 days
What it is
How many days the watch keeps running on one full charge with typical everyday use, including notifications and background heart-rate tracking.
When it matters
Important for travellers and campers who cannot charge daily, and for anyone who wears sleep tracking and dislikes charging at night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm lasts 0.75 days on a charge, which is shorter than 98.2% of Smartwatches and the same as 1.8% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=7 days
Priority:
HIGH
11.0 days
What it is
How many days the watch keeps running on one full charge with typical everyday use, including notifications and background heart-rate tracking.
When it matters
Important for travellers and campers who cannot charge daily, and for anyone who wears sleep tracking and dislikes charging at night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 lasts 11 days on a charge, which is longer than 66.1% of Smartwatches and the same as 2.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=7 days
Priority:
HIGH
Up to 36 hours with battery saver mode or 24 hours with always-on.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the longest battery life.
Battery life in training mode
5.5 h
What it is
The number of hours the watch can keep recording a workout with GPS and heart-rate sensors fully active on one charge.
When it matters
Matters for runners, cyclists and hikers who do long sessions of several hours and need the watch to keep recording until the finish.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm records workouts for 5.5 h on a charge, which is shorter than 90.6% of Smartwatches and the same as 0.5% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=36.8 h
Priority:
MEDIUM
21.0 h
What it is
The number of hours the watch can keep recording a workout with GPS and heart-rate sensors fully active on one charge.
When it matters
Matters for runners, cyclists and hikers who do long sessions of several hours and need the watch to keep recording until the finish.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 records workouts for 21 h on a charge, which is longer than 52% of Smartwatches and the same as 2% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=36.8 h
Priority:
MEDIUM
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the longest training mode battery life.
Battery life with GPS on
6 h
What it is
How many hours the watch runs with GPS switched on, the biggest drain on battery during outdoor activities.
When it matters
Matters for people who record long routes outdoors, such as trail runs or bike rides, and want to know the watch will last the whole ride.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm lasts 6 h with GPS on, which is shorter than 89% of Smartwatches and the same as 2.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=35 h
Priority:
MEDIUM
18 h
What it is
How many hours the watch runs with GPS switched on, the biggest drain on battery during outdoor activities.
When it matters
Matters for people who record long routes outdoors, such as trail runs or bike rides, and want to know the watch will last the whole ride.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 lasts 18 h with GPS on, which is shorter than 60.3% of Smartwatches and the same as 1.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=35 h
Priority:
MEDIUM
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the longest battery life with GPS on.
Battery power
258 mAh
What it is
The capacity of the internal battery, measured in milliamp hours, which sets how much energy the watch can store.
When it matters
Relevant to people who wear the watch around the clock with an always-on display, where a larger cell can mean fewer evening charges, though it adds weight.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a 258 mAh battery, which is smaller than 70.9% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=397 mAh
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has the largest battery capacity.
205 mAh
What it is
The capacity of the internal battery, measured in milliamp hours, which sets how much energy the watch can store.
When it matters
Relevant to people who wear the watch around the clock with an always-on display, where a larger cell can mean fewer evening charges, though it adds weight.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a 205 mAh battery, which is smaller than 86.9% of Smartwatches and the same as 1.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=397 mAh
Priority:
LOW
Charge time
120 min
What it is
How long the watch takes to charge from empty to full using its supplied charger.
When it matters
Useful if you often forget to charge overnight and need a quick top-up before a workout or a day out.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm charges from empty in 120 min, which is quicker than 13.3% of Smartwatches and the same as 44.6% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=102 min
Priority:
MEDIUM
98 min
What it is
How long the watch takes to charge from empty to full using its supplied charger.
When it matters
Useful if you often forget to charge overnight and need a quick top-up before a workout or a day out.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 charges from empty in 98 min, which is quicker than 64% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=102 min
Priority:
MEDIUM
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the quickest charge time.
Wireless charging
yes
What it is
Support for recharging the watch through a charging pad, puck, or other cable-free method.
When it matters
When you want to top up the battery quickly.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports wireless charging. 76.7% of smartwatches support wireless charging.
Priority:
LOW
Wireless charging supported via proprietary charging puck/dock.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports wireless charging.
no
What it is
Support for recharging the watch through a charging pad, puck, or other cable-free method.
When it matters
When you want to top up the battery quickly.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support wireless charging. 23.5% of smartwatches support wireless charging.
Priority:
LOW
Low power mode
yes
What it is
A power-saving mode that reduces features or performance to stretch battery life.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a low power mode. 6.9% of smartwatches include a low power mode.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A power-saving mode that reduces features or performance to stretch battery life.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a low power mode. 6.9% of smartwatches include a low power mode.
Priority:
LOW
Solar power battery
no
What it is
Solar-assisted charging that tops up the battery from light exposure.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support solar charging. 2.4% of smartwatches support solar charging.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
Solar-assisted charging that tops up the battery from light exposure.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support solar charging. 2.4% of smartwatches support solar charging.
Priority:
LOW
Battery level indicator
yes
What it is
A readout that shows remaining battery charge on the watch or in its app.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a battery level indicator. 2.2% of smartwatches include a battery level indicator.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A readout that shows remaining battery charge on the watch or in its app.
When it matters
When you do not want to charge the watch too often.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a battery level indicator. 2.2% of smartwatches include a battery level indicator.
Priority:
LOW
Battery type
Li-ion
What it is
The battery chemistry or construction used inside the watch.
When it matters
When battery lifespan or charging habits matter to you.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses a Li-ion battery type which is less advanced than that of 50.4% of smartwatches and the same as that of 46% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Li-ion
What it is
The battery chemistry or construction used inside the watch.
When it matters
When battery lifespan or charging habits matter to you.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses a Li-ion battery type which is less advanced than that of 50.4% of smartwatches and the same as that of 46% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Sources report rechargeable lithium chemistry as Li-ion or Li-Po.
Smart features
8.6
7.6
Operating system
watchOS
What it is
The software platform the watch runs, which decides which apps, watch faces and phone pairing options you get.
When it matters
When you want third-party apps, a wide range of watch faces, or a watch that pairs with both iPhone and Android.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm runs watchOS, which is more advanced than the system in 96% of Smartwatches and equal to 4% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
MEDIUM
OS detail: watchOS (10.6).
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm runs the most advanced operating system.
Garmin OS
What it is
The software platform the watch runs, which decides which apps, watch faces and phone pairing options you get.
When it matters
When you want third-party apps, a wide range of watch faces, or a watch that pairs with both iPhone and Android.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 runs Garmin OS, which is more advanced than the system in 70.7% of Smartwatches and equal to 9.2% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Software update frequency
ended
What it is
Shows how actively the watch is still updated: regular means ongoing updates throughout active support, occasional means updates every few months or only from time to time, and ended means active software support has mostly stopped.
When it matters
When you care how actively the watch is still supported with fixes, patches, and new features.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has ended software update support which is less active than that of 46.1% of smartwatches and equal to that of 53.9% of smartwatches.
Priority:
MEDIUM
occasional
What it is
Shows how actively the watch is still updated: regular means ongoing updates throughout active support, occasional means updates every few months or only from time to time, and ended means active software support has mostly stopped.
When it matters
When you care how actively the watch is still supported with fixes, patches, and new features.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has occasional software update support which is more active than that of 54% of smartwatches and equal to that of 40.2% of smartwatches.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Updates are typically released about every 3 months.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 gets the latest software updates.
Third-party app support
yes
What it is
Support for installing or using apps from developers beyond the watch maker.
When it matters
When you care about apps, features, and long-term support.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports third-party apps. 48.5% of smartwatches support third-party apps.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Support for installing or using apps from developers beyond the watch maker.
When it matters
When you care about apps, features, and long-term support.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports third-party apps. 48.5% of smartwatches support third-party apps.
Priority:
LOW
Notifications
yes
What it is
Mirroring of calls, messages, apps, or other alerts on the watch.
When it matters
When you want to check alerts without taking out your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports notifications. 0.3% of smartwatches support notifications.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Mirroring of calls, messages, apps, or other alerts on the watch.
When it matters
When you want to check alerts without taking out your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports notifications. 0.3% of smartwatches support notifications.
Priority:
LOW
Voice assistant support
yes
What it is
Support for a voice assistant that can answer queries or trigger actions from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports voice assistants. 30.8% of smartwatches support voice assistants.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports a voice assistant.
no
What it is
Support for a voice assistant that can answer queries or trigger actions from the wrist.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support voice assistants. 69.3% of smartwatches support voice assistants.
Priority:
LOW
Voice commands
yes
What it is
The ability to control functions or start actions using spoken commands.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports voice commands. 31.9% of smartwatches support voice commands.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports voice commands.
no
What it is
The ability to control functions or start actions using spoken commands.
When it matters
When you want to control the watch or reply without typing.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support voice commands. 68.2% of smartwatches support voice commands.
Priority:
LOW
Call control
yes
What it is
The ability to mute, reject, or otherwise manage calls from the watch interface.
When it matters
When you want to handle calls or alerts without taking out your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm offers call control. 8.8% of smartwatches offer call control.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
The ability to mute, reject, or otherwise manage calls from the watch interface.
When it matters
When you want to handle calls or alerts without taking out your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 offers call control. 8.8% of smartwatches offer call control.
Priority:
LOW
Call controls are available, but call audio/conversation is handled on phone or headset.
Call answering
yes
What it is
The ability to answer an incoming call directly from the watch.
When it matters
When you want to handle calls or alerts without taking out your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports call answering. 40% of smartwatches support call answering.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports call answering.
no
What it is
The ability to answer an incoming call directly from the watch.
When it matters
When you want to handle calls or alerts without taking out your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support call answering. 60.1% of smartwatches support call answering.
Priority:
LOW
Music playback
yes
What it is
Playback of music or audio directly from the watch, with or without a phone nearby.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports music playback. 42.9% of smartwatches support music playback.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Playback of music or audio directly from the watch, with or without a phone nearby.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports music playback. 42.9% of smartwatches support music playback.
Priority:
LOW
Camera remote control
yes
What it is
Remote shutter control that lets the watch trigger a paired camera or phone camera.
When it matters
When you want to control your phone camera from the watch.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes built-in camera remote control. 14.5% of smartwatches that are equipped with a camera include built-in camera remote control.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm can control your phone camera remotely.
no
What it is
Remote shutter control that lets the watch trigger a paired camera or phone camera.
When it matters
When you want to control your phone camera from the watch.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include built-in camera remote control. 85.6% of smartwatches that are equipped with a camera include built-in camera remote control.
Priority:
LOW
Calendar sync
yes
What it is
Synchronization of calendar events and schedules between the watch and connected services.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports calendar sync. 4.7% of smartwatches support calendar sync.
Priority:
LOW
Calendar sync depends on compatible paired phone/app ecosystem.
yes
What it is
Synchronization of calendar events and schedules between the watch and connected services.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports calendar sync. 4.7% of smartwatches support calendar sync.
Priority:
LOW
Widget support
yes
What it is
Support for small glanceable panels that show live information or quick actions.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports widgets. 15.6% of smartwatches support widgets.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Support for small glanceable panels that show live information or quick actions.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports widgets. 15.6% of smartwatches support widgets.
Priority:
LOW
Personalization
yes
What it is
Options for customizing watch faces, layouts, shortcuts, or interface style.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports personalization. 1% of smartwatches support personalization.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Options for customizing watch faces, layouts, shortcuts, or interface style.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports personalization. 1% of smartwatches support personalization.
Priority:
LOW
Phone finder
yes
What it is
A feature that helps locate your phone from the watch by triggering alerts or pings.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes phone finder. 3.6% of smartwatches include phone finder.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A feature that helps locate your phone from the watch by triggering alerts or pings.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes phone finder. 3.6% of smartwatches include phone finder.
Priority:
LOW
Passcode
yes
What it is
A lock code or PIN that protects access to the watch and its data.
When it matters
When you want the watch to fit your needs more closely.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes passcode protection. 29.6% of smartwatches include passcode protection.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A lock code or PIN that protects access to the watch and its data.
When it matters
When you want the watch to fit your needs more closely.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes passcode protection. 29.6% of smartwatches include passcode protection.
Priority:
LOW
Gesture control
yes
What it is
Control of watch functions through wrist movements, taps, or hand gestures.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports gesture control. 20.4% of smartwatches support gesture control.
Priority:
LOW
Supports advanced gesture controls (AssistiveTouch/double-tap class features).
yes
What it is
Control of watch functions through wrist movements, taps, or hand gestures.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports gesture control. 20.4% of smartwatches support gesture control.
Priority:
LOW
Stopwatch
yes
What it is
A timer tool for measuring elapsed time directly from the watch.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a stopwatch. 1% of smartwatches include a stopwatch.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A timer tool for measuring elapsed time directly from the watch.
When it matters
When you want quick everyday tools on your wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a stopwatch. 1% of smartwatches include a stopwatch.
Priority:
LOW
Smart alarm
no
What it is
A smart alarm tries to wake you during a lighter sleep phase within a chosen time window instead of at one fixed minute.
When it matters
It matters if you wear your smartwatch overnight and want a gentler wake-up based on your sleep pattern rather than a standard fixed alarm.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support a smart alarm. 50.7% of smartwatches support this feature.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A smart alarm tries to wake you during a lighter sleep phase within a chosen time window instead of at one fixed minute.
When it matters
It matters if you wear your smartwatch overnight and want a gentler wake-up based on your sleep pattern rather than a standard fixed alarm.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports a smart alarm. 49.5% of smartwatches support this feature.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a smart alarm.
Silent alarm
yes
What it is
Alarm functionality that wakes or alerts you through vibration instead of sound.
When it matters
When you want alerts that stay discreet.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports silent alarms. 0.6% of smartwatches support silent alarms.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Alarm functionality that wakes or alerts you through vibration instead of sound.
When it matters
When you want alerts that stay discreet.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports silent alarms. 0.6% of smartwatches support silent alarms.
Priority:
LOW
Vibrating alerts
yes
What it is
Haptic alerts for notifications, calls, timers, and other on-wrist prompts.
When it matters
When you want alerts that stay discreet.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports vibrating alerts. 0.5% of smartwatches support vibrating alerts.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Haptic alerts for notifications, calls, timers, and other on-wrist prompts.
When it matters
When you want alerts that stay discreet.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports vibrating alerts. 0.5% of smartwatches support vibrating alerts.
Priority:
LOW
Emergency SOS
yes
What it is
An emergency feature that can contact help or alert trusted people from the watch.
When it matters
When you want extra help in an emergency.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes Emergency SOS. 55.3% of smartwatches include Emergency SOS.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
An emergency feature that can contact help or alert trusted people from the watch.
When it matters
When you want extra help in an emergency.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes Emergency SOS. 55.3% of smartwatches include Emergency SOS.
Priority:
LOW
SOS feature has implementation limits (phone/app/subscription/activity dependent).
Fall detection
yes
What it is
Automatic detection of hard falls that can trigger checks or emergency actions.
When it matters
When you want extra help in an emergency.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports fall detection. 77.1% of smartwatches support fall detection.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm features fall detection.
no
What it is
Automatic detection of hard falls that can trigger checks or emergency actions.
When it matters
When you want extra help in an emergency.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support fall detection. 23.1% of smartwatches support fall detection.
Priority:
LOW
Crash detection
no
What it is
Detection of severe impacts or crashes that can trigger emergency workflows.
When it matters
When you want extra help in an emergency.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support crash detection. 14.1% of smartwatches support crash detection.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Detection of severe impacts or crashes that can trigger emergency workflows.
When it matters
When you want extra help in an emergency.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports crash detection. 86.1% of smartwatches support crash detection.
Priority:
LOW
Requires paired phone/network and/or specific activities for automatic alerts.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 features crash detection.
Connectivity
7.9
7.3
Cellular module
yes
What it is
Built-in mobile connectivity that can keep the watch online away from the phone.
When it matters
When you want calls, messages, or data without your phone nearby.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a cellular module. 83.5% of smartwatches include a cellular module.
Priority:
LOW
Cellular support may depend on LTE/GPS+Cellular variant selection.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a cellular module.
no
What it is
Built-in mobile connectivity that can keep the watch online away from the phone.
When it matters
When you want calls, messages, or data without your phone nearby.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include a cellular module. 16.7% of smartwatches include a cellular module.
Priority:
LOW
SIM cards
1
What it is
The number or type of SIM options the watch accepts for cellular service.
When it matters
When you want calls, messages, or data without your phone nearby.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses 1 for cellular connectivity which is more advanced than that of 2% of smartwatches and the same as that of 98% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 eSIM support
Priority:
LOW
eSIM on cellular models only.
0
What it is
The number or type of SIM options the watch accepts for cellular service.
When it matters
When you want calls, messages, or data without your phone nearby.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 offers the best cellular support.
Good value:
🎯 eSIM support
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 offers the best cellular support.
GPS
yes
What it is
Built-in satellite positioning that lets the watch record location during outdoor activity.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports GPS. 40.3% of smartwatches support GPS.
Priority:
MEDIUM
yes
What it is
Built-in satellite positioning that lets the watch record location during outdoor activity.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports GPS. 40.3% of smartwatches support GPS.
Priority:
MEDIUM
Galileo support
yes
What it is
Support for Galileo satellites alongside other positioning systems.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports Galileo navigation. 56.5% of smartwatches support Galileo navigation.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Support for Galileo satellites alongside other positioning systems.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports Galileo navigation. 56.5% of smartwatches support Galileo navigation.
Priority:
LOW
Dual-frequency GPS
no
What it is
Whether the watch receives two satellite frequency bands at once, which improves location accuracy near tall buildings and under tree cover.
When it matters
Matters for runners and hikers who record routes in cities or forests, where single-band signals often drift or lose the track.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support dual-frequency GPS. 15.1% of Smartwatches offer this.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
Whether the watch receives two satellite frequency bands at once, which improves location accuracy near tall buildings and under tree cover.
When it matters
Matters for runners and hikers who record routes in cities or forests, where single-band signals often drift or lose the track.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support dual-frequency GPS. 15.1% of Smartwatches offer this.
Priority:
LOW
Compass
no
What it is
A directional sensor that helps the watch determine heading and orientation.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not include a compass. 56.8% of smartwatches include a compass.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A directional sensor that helps the watch determine heading and orientation.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a compass. 43.4% of smartwatches include a compass.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a compass.
Maps support
yes
What it is
The ability to view maps, navigation guidance, or route layouts on the watch.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports maps. 65.7% of smartwatches support maps.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports maps.
no
What it is
The ability to view maps, navigation guidance, or route layouts on the watch.
When it matters
When you run, ride, hike, or navigate without relying on your phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not support maps. 34.4% of smartwatches support maps.
Priority:
LOW
NFC
yes
What it is
Near-field communication hardware used for payments, pairing, or quick tap-based actions.
When it matters
When you want to pay quickly or pair devices with a tap.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports NFC. 54.9% of smartwatches support NFC.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Near-field communication hardware used for payments, pairing, or quick tap-based actions.
When it matters
When you want to pay quickly or pair devices with a tap.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports NFC. 54.9% of smartwatches support NFC.
Priority:
LOW
UWB chip
no
What it is
UWB is an ultra-wideband radio chip used for precise nearby device location and secure short-range interactions.
When it matters
When you want precise finding features, nearby device awareness, or advanced ecosystem features such as directional locating.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not include a UWB chip. 2.3% of smartwatches include UWB.
Good value:
🎯 yes
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
UWB is an ultra-wideband radio chip used for precise nearby device location and secure short-range interactions.
When it matters
When you want precise finding features, nearby device awareness, or advanced ecosystem features such as directional locating.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include a UWB chip. 2.3% of smartwatches include UWB.
Good value:
🎯 yes
Priority:
LOW
Bluetooth version
5.0
What it is
The Bluetooth standard the watch uses to pair with your phone, earbuds and sensors, with newer versions generally offering better range and efficiency.
When it matters
Matters if you pair wireless earbuds, heart-rate straps or cycling sensors, since older versions may connect less reliably with newer accessories.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses Bluetooth 5, which is more current than 31.6% of Smartwatches and the same as 29.5% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=5.1
Priority:
LOW
5.2
What it is
The Bluetooth standard the watch uses to pair with your phone, earbuds and sensors, with newer versions generally offering better range and efficiency.
When it matters
Matters if you pair wireless earbuds, heart-rate straps or cycling sensors, since older versions may connect less reliably with newer accessories.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses Bluetooth 5.2, which is more current than 69% of Smartwatches and the same as 15.2% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=5.1
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the most current Bluetooth version.
Wi-Fi support
yes
What it is
Built-in Wi-Fi that lets the watch connect to wireless networks directly.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work smoothly with your phone and accessories.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm supports Wi-Fi. 56.6% of smartwatches support Wi-Fi.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Built-in Wi-Fi that lets the watch connect to wireless networks directly.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work smoothly with your phone and accessories.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports Wi-Fi. 56.6% of smartwatches support Wi-Fi.
Priority:
LOW
Wi-Fi version
Wi-Fi 4 (802.11 b/g/n)
What it is
The Wi-Fi standard the watch supports for connecting directly to a home network, if it has Wi-Fi at all.
When it matters
Helpful when you want music downloads, app updates or watch-face syncing without your phone nearby, as long as your home router supports the same standard.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses Wi-Fi 4 (802.11 b/g/n), which is more advanced than 60.2% of Smartwatches and the same as 34.7% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Wi-Fi support appears limited to 2.4 GHz networks.
Wi-Fi 5 (802.11ac)
What it is
The Wi-Fi standard the watch supports for connecting directly to a home network, if it has Wi-Fi at all.
When it matters
Helpful when you want music downloads, app updates or watch-face syncing without your phone nearby, as long as your home router supports the same standard.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses Wi-Fi 5 (802.11ac), which is more advanced than 95% of Smartwatches and the same as 3.7% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the most advanced Wi-Fi standard.
ANT+ support
no
What it is
Support for ANT+ accessories such as heart-rate straps, bike sensors, and gym equipment.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not support ANT+. 13% of smartwatches support ANT+.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Support for ANT+ accessories such as heart-rate straps, bike sensors, and gym equipment.
When it matters
When you want the watch to work with fitness gear and other accessories.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports ANT+. 87.1% of smartwatches support ANT+.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 supports ANT+.
iOS compatibility
yes
What it is
Whether the watch can pair with and receive notifications from an iPhone running Apple's iOS.
When it matters
Essential for iPhone owners, since a watch that cannot pair will not show calls, messages or fitness data on the phone.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm works with iOS devices. 5.4% of Smartwatches offer this.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Whether the watch can pair with and receive notifications from an iPhone running Apple's iOS.
When it matters
Essential for iPhone owners, since a watch that cannot pair will not show calls, messages or fitness data on the phone.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 works with iOS devices. 5.4% of Smartwatches offer this.
Priority:
LOW
Android compatibility
no
What it is
Shows how well the smartwatch works with Android pairing, syncing, and core features.
When it matters
When you use an Android phone and want the watch to pair, sync, and keep its main features working properly.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is not compatible with Android. 95.9% of smartwatches are compatible with Android.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Shows how well the smartwatch works with Android pairing, syncing, and core features.
When it matters
When you use an Android phone and want the watch to pair, sync, and keep its main features working properly.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 is compatible with Android. 4.3% of smartwatches are compatible with Android.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 is compatible with Android.
Display & Design
6.7
7.9
Screen size
1.57 inch
What it is
The diagonal size of the display in inches, measured across the active screen area.
When it matters
Matters if you read long messages, follow maps or check detailed workout graphs often, though bigger screens add bulk on small wrists.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a 1.57 inch screen, which is larger than 73.9% of Smartwatches and the same as 1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=1.5 inch
Priority:
LOW
Some sources mention multiple/uncertain size variants.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has the largest screen.
1.2 inch
What it is
The diagonal size of the display in inches, measured across the active screen area.
When it matters
Matters if you read long messages, follow maps or check detailed workout graphs often, though bigger screens add bulk on small wrists.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a 1.2 inch screen, which is smaller than 84.6% of Smartwatches and the same as 8.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=1.5 inch
Priority:
LOW
Display type
OLED
What it is
The screen technology used, which affects colour richness, contrast, outdoor readability and battery use.
When it matters
When you check the watch face in bright sunlight outdoors or want a dark, always-on display at night.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses OLED, which is less advanced than the screen in 53.2% of Smartwatches and equal to 9.1% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Retina branding. LTPO panel wording.
AMOLED
What it is
The screen technology used, which affects colour richness, contrast, outdoor readability and battery use.
When it matters
When you check the watch face in bright sunlight outdoors or want a dark, always-on display at night.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses AMOLED, which is more advanced than the screen in 46.9% of Smartwatches and equal to 53.1% of Smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the most advanced display technology.
Resolution
324x 394
What it is
The total number of pixels available on the watch display.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a display resolution of 324x394 which is lower than that of 55.6% of smartwatches and equal to that of 0.7% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=416 x 416
Priority:
LOW
390x 390
What it is
The total number of pixels available on the watch display.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a display resolution of 390x390 which is higher than that of 56.8% of smartwatches and equal to that of 6% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=416 x 416
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the highest screen resolution.
Pixel density
325 ppi
What it is
How many pixels are packed into each inch of the screen, which determines how crisp text and icons look.
When it matters
When you read short messages, map directions or small fitness figures at a glance.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a pixel density of 325 ppi, which is lower than 55.2% of Smartwatches and equal to 1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=326 ppi
Priority:
LOW
460 ppi
What it is
How many pixels are packed into each inch of the screen, which determines how crisp text and icons look.
When it matters
When you read short messages, map directions or small fitness figures at a glance.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a pixel density of 460 ppi, which is higher than 80.1% of Smartwatches and equal to 4.8% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=326 ppi
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has the sharpest screen.
Display brightness
1,000 nit
What it is
The peak brightness of the screen, measured in nits, which determines how easily it can be read in direct sunlight.
When it matters
When you run or cycle outdoors on sunny days and need the screen readable without shading it with your hand.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a screen brightness of 1,000 nits, which is higher than 53.5% of Smartwatches and equal to 27% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=1000 nits
Priority:
LOW
?
Always-On Display
no
What it is
A display mode that keeps key information visible even when the watch is idle.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not have an always-on display. 70.4% of smartwatches have an always-on display.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A display mode that keeps key information visible even when the watch is idle.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has an always-on display. 29.7% of smartwatches have an always-on display.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 features an always-on display.
Touch screen
yes
What it is
Direct touch input on the display for navigating menus, apps, and quick controls.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a touch screen. 8.5% of smartwatches have a touch screen.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
Direct touch input on the display for navigating menus, apps, and quick controls.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a touch screen. 8.5% of smartwatches have a touch screen.
Priority:
LOW
Ambient light sensor
yes
What it is
A sensor that detects surrounding light to adjust screen behavior or brightness.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes an ambient light sensor. 36.6% of smartwatches include an ambient light sensor.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A sensor that detects surrounding light to adjust screen behavior or brightness.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes an ambient light sensor. 36.6% of smartwatches include an ambient light sensor.
Priority:
LOW
Display glass type
Ion-X
What it is
The glass material or protective cover used over the display.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses Ion-X display glass which is less durable than that of 57.2% of smartwatches and the same as that of 4.1% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 Sapphire or Gorilla Glass
Priority:
LOW
Corning Gorilla Glass 3
What it is
The glass material or protective cover used over the display.
When it matters
When you want the screen to be easy to read at a glance.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses Corning Gorilla Glass 3 display glass which is more durable than that of 54.9% of smartwatches and the same as that of 20.6% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 Sapphire or Gorilla Glass
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses premium display glass.
IP rating
?
?
Waterproof depth rating
50 m
What it is
The maximum depth in metres the watch is rated to be submerged in still water without leaking.
When it matters
When you swim in a pool or open water, or dive or snorkel with the watch on your wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is rated to 50 m, which is deeper than 43.4% of Smartwatches and equal to 48.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=50 m
Priority:
LOW
50 m
What it is
The maximum depth in metres the watch is rated to be submerged in still water without leaking.
When it matters
When you swim in a pool or open water, or dive or snorkel with the watch on your wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 is rated to 50 m, which is deeper than 43.4% of Smartwatches and equal to 48.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=50 m
Priority:
LOW
5 ATM class (ISO 22,810 shallow-water rating, not diving certification).
Rugged design
no
What it is
A build style aimed at tougher environments, impacts, and harsher outdoor use.
When it matters
When you wear the watch in rain, sweat, or water.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not have a rugged design. 41.3% of smartwatches have a rugged design.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A build style aimed at tougher environments, impacts, and harsher outdoor use.
When it matters
When you wear the watch in rain, sweat, or water.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not have a rugged design. 41.3% of smartwatches have a rugged design.
Priority:
LOW
Weight
30.1 g
What it is
The mass of the complete watch including case, strap and battery, measured in grams.
When it matters
When you wear it to bed for sleep tracking or all day, since extra grams add up on a smaller wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm weighs 30.1 g, which is lighter than 87.9% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=37 g
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is the lightest.
36.0 g
What it is
The mass of the complete watch including case, strap and battery, measured in grams.
When it matters
When you wear it to bed for sleep tracking or all day, since extra grams add up on a smaller wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 weighs 36 g, which is lighter than 72.2% of Smartwatches and equal to 1.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=37 g
Priority:
LOW
Thickness
10.7 mm
What it is
The depth of the case from the back to the top of the glass, which determines how much it protrudes from the wrist.
When it matters
When you wear it under a shirt cuff or a jacket sleeve, where a thick case snags and sits awkwardly.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is 10.7 mm thick, which is slimmer than 75.6% of Smartwatches and equal to 3.5% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=10.9 mm
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has the slimmest case.
11.1 mm
What it is
The depth of the case from the back to the top of the glass, which determines how much it protrudes from the wrist.
When it matters
When you wear it under a shirt cuff or a jacket sleeve, where a thick case snags and sits awkwardly.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 is 11.1 mm thick, which is slimmer than 62.8% of Smartwatches and equal to 1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=10.9 mm
Priority:
LOW
Height
40.0 mm
What it is
The vertical size of the case from top to bottom, which sets how much of the wrist the watch covers.
When it matters
When you have a narrow wrist or wear the watch under a sleeve, where a tall case can feel bulky.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is 40 mm tall, which is shorter than 88.6% of Smartwatches and equal to 1.7% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=12.6 mm
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has the shortest case.
42.2 mm
What it is
The vertical size of the case from top to bottom, which sets how much of the wrist the watch covers.
When it matters
When you have a narrow wrist or wear the watch under a sleeve, where a tall case can feel bulky.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 is 42.2 mm tall, which is shorter than 74% of Smartwatches and equal to 0.1% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=12.6 mm
Priority:
LOW
Width
34.0 mm
What it is
The side-to-side size of the case, measured across the widest part of the watch face.
When it matters
When you have a small wrist or want a watch that does not overhang the edges of the wrist.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm measures 34 mm, which is narrower than 91.6% of Smartwatches and equal to 0.8% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=39 mm
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has the narrowest case.
42.2 mm
What it is
The side-to-side size of the case, measured across the widest part of the watch face.
When it matters
When you have a small wrist or want a watch that does not overhang the edges of the wrist.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 measures 42.2 mm, which is narrower than 50.8% of Smartwatches and equal to 0.3% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=39 mm
Priority:
LOW
Width of band
22 mm
What it is
The width of the strap where it meets the case, which changes both the look and how the strap feels on the wrist.
When it matters
When you choose a replacement strap, since band width decides which aftermarket straps and quick-release pins will fit.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a 22 mm strap, which is narrower than 8.4% of Smartwatches and equal to 57.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 18-22 mm
Priority:
LOW
22 mm
What it is
The width of the strap where it meets the case, which changes both the look and how the strap feels on the wrist.
When it matters
When you choose a replacement strap, since band width decides which aftermarket straps and quick-release pins will fit.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a 22 mm strap, which is narrower than 8.4% of Smartwatches and equal to 57.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 18-22 mm
Priority:
LOW
Case material
aluminum, stainless steel
What it is
The main material used for the watch case.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses aluminum, stainless steel for the case material which is more premium than that of 82.7% of smartwatches and the same as that of 3% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 Aluminium, stainless steel, or titanium
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses premium watch case materials.
aluminum, fiber-reinforced polymer
What it is
The main material used for the watch case.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses aluminum, fiber-reinforced polymer for the case material which is more premium than that of 49.8% of smartwatches and the same as that of 1.2% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 Aluminium, stainless steel, or titanium
Priority:
LOW
Band material
silicone
What it is
The main material used for the watch strap or band.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses silicone for the band material which is more premium than that of 9.9% of smartwatches and the same as that of 53.9% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
fluoroelastomer Sport Band
silicone
What it is
The main material used for the watch strap or band.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses silicone for the band material which is more premium than that of 9.9% of smartwatches and the same as that of 53.9% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Replaceable band
yes
What it is
A strap system that can be detached and swapped for a different compatible band.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a replaceable band. 1.2% of smartwatches include a replaceable band.
Priority:
LOW
yes
What it is
A strap system that can be detached and swapped for a different compatible band.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 includes a replaceable band. 1.2% of smartwatches include a replaceable band.
Priority:
LOW
Form
rectangular
What it is
The overall design form, such as round, square, or another case shape.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses a rectangular watch form which is less practical than that of 74.4% of smartwatches and the same as that of 25.5% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
round
What it is
The overall design form, such as round, square, or another case shape.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 uses a round watch form which is more practical than that of 37.3% of smartwatches and the same as that of 62.7% of smartwatches.
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 offers the best watch form factor.
Hybrid design
no
What it is
A watch design that mixes smart features with traditional analog or low-power elements.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not have a hybrid design. 8.6% of smartwatches have a hybrid design.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A watch design that mixes smart features with traditional analog or low-power elements.
When it matters
When you wear the watch all day or sleep with it on.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not have a hybrid design. 8.6% of smartwatches have a hybrid design.
Priority:
LOW
Kid-friendly design
no
What it is
A child-oriented design focused on smaller wrists, simpler controls, or safer materials.
When it matters
When the watch is for a child and daily comfort matters.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not have a kid-friendly design. 1.5% of smartwatches have a kid-friendly design.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A child-oriented design focused on smaller wrists, simpler controls, or safer materials.
When it matters
When the watch is for a child and daily comfort matters.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not have a kid-friendly design. 1.5% of smartwatches have a kid-friendly design.
Priority:
LOW
Maximum operating temperature
35 °C
What it is
The highest ambient temperature the watch is rated to work in without its battery or screen being damaged.
When it matters
When you leave the watch in a hot car, use it in a sauna, or wear it in a hot climate in full sun.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is rated up to 35 °C, which is lower than 83.3% of Smartwatches and equal to 16.7% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=45 °C
Priority:
LOW
60 °C
What it is
The highest ambient temperature the watch is rated to work in without its battery or screen being damaged.
When it matters
When you leave the watch in a hot car, use it in a sauna, or wear it in a hot climate in full sun.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 is rated up to 60 °C, which is higher than 86.1% of Smartwatches and equal to 12.7% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=45 °C
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 handles the highest temperatures.
Minimum operating temperature
0 °C
What it is
The coldest ambient temperature the watch is rated to work in, which matters for winter and mountain use.
When it matters
When you run or walk outdoors in winter, ski, or hike at altitude where temperatures drop below freezing.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm is rated down to 0 °C, which is higher than 59.2% of Smartwatches and equal to 38.7% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=-20 °C
Priority:
LOW
-20 °C
What it is
The coldest ambient temperature the watch is rated to work in, which matters for winter and mountain use.
When it matters
When you run or walk outdoors in winter, ski, or hike at altitude where temperatures drop below freezing.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 is rated down to -20 °C, which is lower than 61.2% of Smartwatches and equal to 37.4% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 <=-20 °C
Priority:
LOW
Garmin Vivoactive 5 works in the coldest conditions.
Hardware
7.0
1.3
CPU speed
2x 1.5 GHz
What it is
The clock speed of the watch processor, usually expressed in GHz or MHz.
When it matters
When you want apps and menus to feel smooth.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses a CPU configuration of 2x1.5 GHz which is faster than that in 76.5% of smartwatches and equal to that in 1.2% of smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 Modern standard
Priority:
LOW
?
Processor model
Apple S4
What it is
The processor model is the chipset or SoC that powers the watch's performance, connectivity, and efficiency.
When it matters
When you care about app responsiveness, platform generation, and long-term feature support.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm uses the Apple S4 processor model.
Good value:
🎯 modern smartwatch chipset
Priority:
LOW
?
RAM
1 GB
What it is
The working memory the watch uses to run apps, watch faces and background tasks at the same time.
When it matters
When you want to run several third-party apps, store offline music, or keep the watch responsive after months of software updates.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has 1 GB of RAM, which is more than 34.1% of Smartwatches and equal to 41.8% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=1 GB
Priority:
LOW
?
Internal storage
16 GB
What it is
The built-in flash memory where the watch keeps apps, music, photos and watch faces.
When it matters
When you want to load offline playlists for a run or keep maps and several apps on the watch so you can leave the phone at home.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has 16 GB of internal storage, which is more than 77% of Smartwatches and equal to 4.2% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=8 GB
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has the most internal storage.
4 GB
What it is
The built-in flash memory where the watch keeps apps, music, photos and watch faces.
When it matters
When you want to load offline playlists for a run or keep maps and several apps on the watch so you can leave the phone at home.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has 4 GB of internal storage, which is more than 39.8% of Smartwatches and equal to 25.5% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=8 GB
Priority:
LOW
External memory slot
no
What it is
A slot for expandable storage such as a memory card, if the watch provides one.
When it matters
When you want more room for apps, music, or offline data.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not include an external memory slot. 0.3% of smartwatches include an external memory slot.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A slot for expandable storage such as a memory card, if the watch provides one.
When it matters
When you want more room for apps, music, or offline data.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include an external memory slot. 0.3% of smartwatches include an external memory slot.
Priority:
LOW
Camera
no
What it is
Whether the watch includes a camera for photos, video, or calling.
When it matters
When you want to take photos or video calls from the watch itself.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not include a camera. 1.8% of smartwatches include a camera.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
Whether the watch includes a camera for photos, video, or calling.
When it matters
When you want to take photos or video calls from the watch itself.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include a camera. 1.8% of smartwatches include a camera.
Priority:
LOW
Camera megapixels
N/A
N/A
Built-in speaker
yes
What it is
An onboard speaker for calls, prompts, alarms, or media playback.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm includes a built-in speaker. 43.4% of smartwatches include a built-in speaker.
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a built-in speaker.
no
What it is
An onboard speaker for calls, prompts, alarms, or media playback.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include a built-in speaker. 56.8% of smartwatches include a built-in speaker.
Priority:
LOW
Number of microphones
1
What it is
How many microphones the watch uses to pick up your voice for calls, dictation and voice commands.
When it matters
When you take calls on the watch on a noisy street or dictate messages while running, where extra microphones help filter out wind and traffic.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has a microphone count of 1, which is more than 27.1% of Smartwatches and equal to 67.5% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=2
Priority:
LOW
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm has the most microphones.
0
What it is
How many microphones the watch uses to pick up your voice for calls, dictation and voice commands.
When it matters
When you take calls on the watch on a noisy street or dictate messages while running, where extra microphones help filter out wind and traffic.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 has a microphone count of 0, which is fewer than 73% of Smartwatches and equal to 27% of Smartwatches.
Good value:
🎯 >=2
Priority:
LOW
3.5 mm audio jack
no
What it is
A standard headphone jack for wired audio accessories.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Apple Watch Series 4 40mm does not include a 3.5 mm audio jack. 0.5% of smartwatches include a 3.5 mm audio jack.
Priority:
LOW
no
What it is
A standard headphone jack for wired audio accessories.
When it matters
When you want audio, calls, or voice features on the watch itself.
Garmin Vivoactive 5 does not include a 3.5 mm audio jack. 0.5% of smartwatches include a 3.5 mm audio jack.
Priority:
LOW

Best alternatives to the Apple Watch Series 4 40mm and the Garmin Vivoactive 5

Other models worth a look, with one reason each against the Apple Watch Series 4 40mm and Garmin Vivoactive 5.

8.5~£150
Higher overall score (8.5 vs 8.1) and about £10 cheaper
Compare with the Garmin Vivoactive 5 →
8.3~£180
Higher overall score (8.3 vs 8.1) and better internal storage: 32 GB against 16 GB
Compare with the Garmin Vivoactive 5 →
8.0~£160
Better battery power: 455 mAh against 258 mAh
Compare with the Garmin Vivoactive 5 →
8.1~£180
Better internal storage: 32 GB against 16 GB
Compare with the Garmin Vivoactive 5 →
8.0~£180
Better battery life in training mode: 44 h against 21 h
Compare with the Garmin Vivoactive 5 →
7.9~£180
Better battery life with GPS on: 30 h against 18 h
Compare with the Garmin Vivoactive 5 →

Apple Watch Series 4 40mm vs Garmin Vivoactive 5: questions people ask

Which is better, the Apple Watch Series 4 40mm or the Garmin Vivoactive 5?

The Garmin Vivoactive 5 scores 8.1 overall against 7.9 for the Apple Watch Series 4 40mm.

Which is cheaper, the Apple Watch Series 4 40mm or the Garmin Vivoactive 5?

The Apple Watch Series 4 40mm: £160 against £180 for the Garmin Vivoactive 5.

Which is better for hiking?

The Apple Watch Series 4 40mm: 8.3 against 1.9 out of 10 on our hiking score.

Comparison of Apple Watch Series 4 40mm and Garmin Vivoactive 5 with other products

1Product to compare no. 1
VS
2Product to compare no. 2
VS
3Product to compare no. 3 (optional)

Graphical comparison of Apple Watch Series 4 40mm and Garmin Vivoactive 5 with all other products

No results found