Apple Watch Edition Review | 126 Data compared

The Münstersche Zeitung review of the Apple Watch Series 2 highlights significant hardware upgrades, specifically the addition of built-in GPS for independent tracking and a much brighter 1000-nit display. Key pros include 50-metre water resistance with specialized swimming tracking and a faster dual-core S2 processor, which addresses previous performance lag. On the downside, the review notes that battery life remains a limitation, requiring daily charging despite the hardware improvements. Furthermore, heavy use of the GPS functionality can cause rapid battery drain, and the device still lacks an always-on display feature. Ultimately, the Series 2 is presented as a more 'complete' smartwatch compared to its predecessor, particularly for fitness enthusiasts. While watchOS 3 improves older models, the hardware advancements in the Series 2 make it a better, though more expensive, choice for active users.

The Stern review highlights the Apple Watch Series 2 as a significant shift toward fitness, specifically praising its new swim-tracking capabilities, 50-meter water resistance, and a 'clever trick' where the speaker ejects water via the Digital Crown. The review notes that while the watch is suitable for swimming, it should not be used for high-velocity water sports or saunas. Performance is enhanced by a new dual-core processor, while the screen's brightness (1,000 nits) makes it highly readable in direct sunlight. A key 'pro' is the integrated GPS, which allows for accurate, phone-free tracking for runners and swimmers, such as the 400-meter test highlighted in the article. Among the 'cons,' the design is nearly identical to the original, and the battery still requires nightly charging, with rapid draining under GPS use. Additionally, the reviewer notes that the device's seals can be sensitive to chemicals found in shampoos and lotions, which can affect long-term water resistance.

The Apple Watch Series 3 (LTE) 42mm earned high praise for its integrated eSIM and LTE module, enabling standalone functionality for calls, messages, and music streaming, according to CHIP [1.1]. The device features a faster S3 dual-core processor and a barometric altimeter for elevation tracking, while maintaining the same compact, waterproof design as its predecessor [1.1]. Enhanced fitness tracking includes 24/7 heart rate monitoring and swimming capability, with a 1.52-inch OLED display that is both bright and clear, despite lacking an always-on feature [1.1]. The W2 wireless chip contributes to better efficiency, offering over 30 hours of battery life in typical usage [1.1]. Key drawbacks noted by CHIP include the lack of support for standard watch straps and significant battery drain when actively using cellular or GPS features [1.1]. The watch is highlighted for its comprehensive functionality and independence from an iPhone, effectively delivering on the promise of a standalone wearable [1.1].

The Welt review highlights the Apple Watch Series 2 as a significant evolution, transforming from a general gadget into a dedicated fitness and health companion. Key improvements include built-in GPS for untethered workouts, a display that is twice as bright (1,000 nits) for better outdoor visibility, and full waterproofing up to 50 meters, which includes a mechanism to eject water from the speaker. Performance is enhanced by the dual-core S2 processor, resulting in a snappier user experience with faster app loading and smoother animations. A major limitation noted is the stagnant battery life, requiring near-daily charging, especially when using GPS. Additionally, the device is slightly thicker (0.9mm) than the original model to accommodate the new components. The review concludes the Series 2 is the premier smartwatch-fitness hybrid, though it remains a premium, non-essential purchase. It is recommended for athletes and swimmers, but existing Apple Watch users might not find the performance boost and hardware upgrades necessary to justify the cost, as many features are available through watchOS 3.

The initial Apple Watch is characterized as a premium, well-crafted device featuring a high-resolution OLED display and intuitive Digital Crown navigation. Key pros include seamless iPhone integration, effective notification management, and convenient mobile payments. The design is widely praised, offering a stylish, customizable aesthetic superior to contemporary competitors. Major cons center on the first-generation limitations, specifically the battery, which demands daily charging, and the lack of built-in GPS, requiring a paired iPhone for route tracking. Additionally, users reported that third-party applications often load slowly, detracting from the overall responsiveness. While recognized as the most capable smartwatch at launch, the interface can be complex, and the 'wrist raise' feature sometimes fails to activate instantly. The review concludes that while it is an ambitious, polished product, it is not yet an essential device, serving instead as a strong foundation for future, faster iterations.

The Apple Watch Series 2 stainless steel model transitions from a fashion accessory to a capable fitness tool, featuring built-in GPS and 50-meter water resistance that allows for independent, phone-free tracking. The premium stainless steel casing is paired with a sapphire glass display that boasts 1,000 nits brightness for superior outdoor visibility, though the device is slightly thicker than its predecessor. Performance is enhanced by the S2 dual-core processor, which increases responsiveness, while key pros include accurate, dedicated swim tracking and a novel water-ejection system. The durable stainless steel construction and brighter screen make it a significant, resilient upgrade over the original Apple Watch. Key drawbacks noted in the review include the lack of an always-on display and a battery that, while improved, still requires daily charging, especially with active GPS use. Despite improvements, the device remains heavily reliant on an iPhone, and the premium stainless steel model comes with a high entry price.